The Environmental Journal of Southern Appalachia
Sunday, 23 February 2025 15:00

Updated 2/28: Energy secretary on visit to an uncertain Oak Ridge shrugs at climate change; offers little concrete update on federal cuts

Written by

U.S. Sen. Bill Hagerty, R-Tenn.; U.S. Secretary of Energy Chris Wright; Rep. Chuck Fleischmann; R-Chattanooga; and Open AI CEO Greg Brockman spoke with the press during a tour of Oak Ridge-area nuclear facilities.  Ben Pounds/Hellbender Press

Visit by energy secretary doesn’t address program cuts as former fracking CEO downplays climate change threat; visit comes following diversity program cuts; full extent of Oak Ridge impacts still unknown

Hellbender Press typically avoids the use of anonymous sources. The sources in this story spoke on condition they not be identified so they could speak on a sensitive matter.

This story will be updated. The original stories continue below.

OAK RIDGE  U.S. Secretary of Energy Chris Wright denied that climate change was a “crisis” and downplayed its threat during a visit to an international hub of scientific expertise rattled by early actions of the second Trump Administration. His visit did little to allay fears of cuts to staff and programs at Oak Ridge National Laboratory, where the most concrete signs of change have been the dismantling of diversity efforts.

Wright visited ORNL on Feb. 28, and at a press conference defended the Trump administration’s actions on climate change, energy sources and the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), a group headed by Elon Musk that has recommended cutting programs and staff in various government departments.

He did not announce any layoffs at the lab itself, however, and implied research related to climate there will continue. Oak Ridge National Laboratory is home to many kinds of related research, including at the Climate Change Science Institute. CCSI does modeling and gathers data on the climate, as well as working on solutions to the problem.

Wright promoted research on artificial intelligence, which he called “Manhattan Project II,” and nuclear energy, and he appeared alongside Sen. Bill Hagerty, R-Tenn., Rep. Chuck Fleischmann R-Chattanooga and Open AI CEO Greg Brockman, who also spoke and answered questions. 

“I don’t think you’ll see any reduction in the science that we do regarding climate change or any of these other really big questions,” said Wright in response to a reporter’s questions about how cuts at the lab might affect climate change-related research at ORNL, which his department funds through a partnership with contractor Battelle and the University of Tennessee. He said, however, he still “100 percent” believed there was no climate “crisis” and said scientific reports backed up his view. 

“We haven’t seen an increase in the frequency or intensity of hurricanes, floods, droughts, storms. Wildfires are on an uptick because we stopped managing our forests,” he said. “Deaths from extreme weather, which is what you hear the press and politicians’ fearmongering about, it declined over 90 percent in my lifetime as the population’s grown. So climate change is a real phenomenon. It’s just not even remotely close to the world’s biggest problem.” He also said an intergovernmental climate change report also showed economists saying climate change was not as important as issues like education, free trade and “empowerment.”

These claims are a mixed bag of truth. While the frequency of hurricanes hitting the United States, for example, hasn’t increased, a recent Columbia University study showed the tropical cyclones’ intensity for the East and Gulf Coasts has. Also unmentioned by Wright was any impact the climate has on disease or health conditions apart from extreme weather, a subject on which experts at Tennessee’s own Vanderbilt University have sounded the alarm.

Wright was CEO of a hydraulic fracking company, Liberty Energy, before his appointment.

“It’s a real thing, but nothing in the science of climate change or in the economics of climate change shows it to be the world’s biggest problem,” Wright said. “When you call something a crisis, it means we don’t have time to stop and think. We’ve just got to take action. That’s exactly the opposite of what climate science is.”

During the meeting, he also defended Musk, DOGE and Trump’s actions generally while not announcing any such cuts for the civilian research at Oak Ridge National Laboratory or the weapons maintenance at Y-12, which is managed by a different contractor. A reporter at the event mentioned an earlier instance in which workers at Y-12 National Security Complex received termination letters that were then rescinded. While the reporter asked him to offer reassurance on job security, he sidestepped that question.

“We have an effort to make the federal government more efficient. That means, deliver more services more efficiently,” he said. “Of course you’ll see some reduction in total headcount. I don’t think here at a cutting-edge national lab that that’s an issue at all. I wouldn’t worry about that.” He called Trump “passionate” about nuclear defense even amid his call to spend less on it.

Wright, like his predecessor Secretary of Energy Jennifer Granholm, promoted nuclear power as part of an overall strategy. Wright, like Granholm, visited the future site of the Tennessee Valley Authority’s Small Modular Reactor a new type of nuclear power plant.


The Sept. 26 update of the original story continues here:

Diversity efforts slashed; full range of federal defunding consequences still unclear in Oak Ridge

The full impacts to scientific research at one of the top federal labs in the nation remain uncertain following a rash of executive orders and legal permutations. It can be noted, however, that the Trump administration is definitively ending programs meant to encourage racial diversity in Oak Ridge National Laboratory research projects.

The Department of Energy Office of Science discouraged people looking for grants from measures meant to include minorities and members of disadvantaged groups publicly and in an email. Meanwhile, the DOE site office for Oak Ridge National Laboratory is reportedly down from 46 billets to 30, and an anonymous source confirmed staff are trying to figure out the Trump administration’s research priorities.

“Apparently the new administration's directives are not cut and dry,” the source, who works for ORNL, said.

The source confirmed that ORNL director Stephen Streiffer told employees not to be concerned during an all-hands-on-deck meeting Feb. 24. Streiffer reportedly said that apart from a disagreement over liquified natural gas exports, the new administration’s priorities line up with the lab’s specialties. However, he reportedly said people may need to shift focus, without giving specifics.

“At one point, he emphasized that scientists are limited to study what is funded,” the source said. The source said another person in the meeting involved in environmental and biological sciences reportedly implied his directorate might focus less on climate change. 

The employee source confidentially forwarded an email they received, and the wording is the same as on a public website.  The Office of Science announced ending its requirement to include Promoting Inclusive and Equitable Research (PIER) plans in any proposals to the office. These plans can, for instance, include involving people from backgrounds that typically aren’t involved in the project’s research field. The email and page state the office will simply ignore these plans when choosing whether to fund proposals that have already gone out.

Both the email and the website, however, go further, stating DOE is ending, “diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) policies, procedures, programs, activities, and reviews involving or relating to DEI objectives and principles until further notice.” Specifically, DOE will no longer use Justice40 priorities when deciding on loans or contracts. Justice40 was a Biden-era goal that 40 percent of “the overall benefits of certain Federal climate, clean energy, affordable and sustainable housing, and other investments flow to disadvantaged communities that are marginalized by underinvestment and overburdened by pollution” as per an archived official website.

The Office of Science stated in the email it will also no longer use or require Community Benefits Plans, another change that will possibly affect environmental, labor, workplace safety and other issues.

A Biden-era presentation lays out that those plans involved formal agreements among “community, labor and tribal partners” and tracking the benefits and costs the measures have for the relevant communities. Such a plan should “describe both positive and negative impact on local air, water and/or land quality.”

Other aspects of a Community Benefits plan involve creating “good-paying jobs to attract and retain skilled workers” with workplace health and safety plans and creating “equitable access to wealth building opportunities” for disadvantaged groups. The plan involved relevant agencies having milestones to achieve these goals.


More of the original Feb. 23 story:

Streiffer in turn, has reportedly met with Secretary of Energy Christopher Wright. One source said that a companywide email had told employees not to mention a specific diversity program when applying for grants; another said a diversity and inclusion program had ended. Neither said they knew if any research programs or funding had been suspended.

The University of Tennessee and Batelle run Oak Ridge National Laboratory for the Department of Energy, meaning that it’s not as tightly controlled as some other federal programs. Recent research there has included quantum internet, nuclear energy technologies, alternative fuels for boats, plastics recycling, and absorbing lithium that’s leached from used batteries and mine sites out of wastewater.

The upcoming meeting comes amid an uncertain time for federal programs, including environmental research. President Donald Trump issued the executive order “Unleashing American Energy” on Jan. 20, ordering all federal agencies “immediately pause” all funds earmarked from the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 and the Infrastructure and Jobs Act of 2021, both of which are laws that Congress passed and funded and President Joseph Biden signed. The order demands a review of the relevant programming to ensure it is in keeping with Trump’s priorities.

The Inflation Reduction Act provided ORNL a total of $497 million in funding in 2022, which came through the Department of Energy’s Office of Science, including for programs related to climate change and nuclear energy. US District Judge John McConnell Jr. ordered the administration release the grant funds from the IRA at least through Feb. 21. None of the official sources confirmed changes due to the executive order or the judge’s action, and the two anonymous sources said they did not know of any effects it had.

ORNL and the University of Tennessee have directed Hellbender’s questions to the DOE, which has not commented as of press time. Public information officers or spokespersons on a national scale have not responded to reporter queries on DOGE’s direct or pending impacts at multiple federal agencies and departments.

While people often discuss the two together, ORNL is separate from Y-12 National Security Complex on the other side of town, where people have noticed the new administration’s actions more blatantly. It’s also tied to the Department of Energy, but through a different branch, the National Nuclear Security Administration, and a different contractor, Consolidated Nuclear Security. While the lab focuses on civilian technologies, Y-12, maintains the USA’s nuclear weapons.

USA Today network and Reuters have reported the Trump Administration fired workers at Y-12 along with other NNSA workers before trying to hire them back.

Rate this item
(2 votes)
Last modified on Thursday, 13 March 2025 00:48