The Environmental Journal of Southern Appalachia

Tennessee Lookout: TWRA delays clearcut in Cumberlands as tourism official files suit

Written by

DSCF8531 scaledMarvin Bullock, president of the Sparta-White County Chamber of Commerce, opposes deforestation efforts in the Bridgestone-Firestone Centennial Wilderness Area to create quail habitat. John Partipillo/Courtesy of Tennessee Lookout

Oak Ridge Rep. John Ragan joins bipartisan pushback against state plans to raze forest for quail habitat

This story was originally published by Tennessee Lookout.

SPARTA — For decades, the Tennessee Wildlife Resources Agency has kept the profits from the sale of timber and other natural resources on publicly owned lands, folding the payments from logging companies into the agency’s annual operating budget.

bipartisan bill introduced in the Tennessee Legislature this week seeks to bring that practice to an end. The measure, introduced by Rep. John Ragan, R-Oak Ridge, and Sen. Heidi Campbell, D-Nashville, would require TWRA officials to transfer all proceeds from the sale of the state’s natural resources into Tennessee’s general fund — the process typically followed by other Tennessee agencies that generate income.

TWRA has earned more than $7.5 million from timber sales on public lands since July 2011, according to sales data obtained by the Tennessee Lookout.

The agency is poised to earn significantly more revenue as a result of a controversial plan to raze 2,000 forested acres in the publicly-owned Bridgestone Firestone Centennial Wilderness Area, a popular hunting and recreation area near Sparta. The plan aligns with agency objectives to create more grassland habitat for declining numbers of Northern bobwhite quail, the official game bird of Tennessee.  TWRA officials announced in December they would begin taking bids from loggers in February.

Ragan, who serves as co-chair of the House Government Operations Committee, said Wednesday he had no specific complaints about TWRA. He is cosponsoring the bill, he said, as a matter of “good governance” to bring the agency in line the rest of state government.

“They should be like the others,” he said. “It’s not so much that they have done anything that’s heinous or anything like that.”

The TWRA operates with a level of financial independence that sets it apart from other state agencies. On the agency website, it prominently notes that — unlike other state departments, which are supported through tax revenues — the TWRA is funded largely through the revenues generated from hunting and fishing licenses, timber and other sales. Those funds are earmarked exclusively for use by the agency, not transferred into the state’s general fund.

Campbell, who has been critical of TWRA plans to deforest portions of the Bridgestone property, said the bill is designed to introduce more transparency and oversight to the work of the agency.

“I think fiscal responsibility is important to all Tennesseans,” Campbell said. “People in our state government don’t know what’s going on with the TWRA. This bill would bring the same oversight that every other division of state government operates under.”

Environmental advocates and White County residents and officials opposed to the Bridgestone plans have criticized TWRA’s timber sales as providing a perverse incentive for TWRA officials to increase the size of their own agency budget.

Campbell and Ragan are among the 34 Tennessee lawmakers who on Tuesday sent a letter to Bobby Wilson, TWRA’s executive director, accusing his agency of “breaching its duty to protect natural wildlife in Tennessee.” The bipartisan message criticized the agency’s plan to deforest 2,000 acres on the Bridgestone land in White County and urged the agency to “stop all action on the plan immediately.”

It remains unclear whether agency officials plan to accede to lawmakers’ demands.

On Wednesday, News Channel 9 in Chattanooga reported that clearcutting plans in the Bridgestone Firestone Centennial Wilderness are suspended temporarily. The TV station reported quoted Wilson, the TWRA executive director, as saying he “will be suspending any plans to do cutting until this situation is resolved.”

However, Tracey Boyers, TWRA’s general counsel, decline to confirm the accuracy of TV report to the Lookout on Wednesday, writing in an email that “this matter is currently the subject of pending litigation and the Agency does not comment on matters in litigation.”

Boyers did not respond to further questions, including TWRA’s perspective on the bill introduced by Campbell and Ragan.

TWRA officials have not communicated any change in plans to community officials or local residents who would be the most directly impacted by clearcutting plans on the public lands that serve as a key component of their local economy — drawing tourists, hunters, hikers, kayakers and retirees.

Last week, Marvin Bullock, president of the Sparta/White County Chamber of Commerce, served TWRA with a 60-day notice of his intent to sue under the Endangered Species Act should plans move forward on land that, he said, is home to at least six endangered species and more than 30 species of plants and animals that are of state and federal concern.

Bullock’s attorney, Austin Warehime, said Wednesday that neither he nor Bullock have received any communication about a temporary pause on clearcutting plans.

“There’s been a lot of frustration that they have absolutely not communicated with what’s going on on a piece of property that is very dear to (local residents),” Warehime said.

Bullock is “cautiously optimistic” after hearing that TWRA may be suspending their clearcutting plans from the TV report.  But Bullock is also “concerned that the public will believe the war is over. This is just a small battle, until TWRA completely scraps the plan, the endangered species aren’t safe,” Warehime said.

Rate this item
(2 votes)
Published in News

Related items

  • Every TVA coal-fired plant in Tennessee is leaking dangerous contaminants at unsafe levels, report concludes
    in News

    TVA‘s Cumberland power plantThe Tennessee Valley Authority’s Cumberland Fossil Plant in Stewart County, Tennessee is leaking boron at 22 times safe levels, as well as unsafe levels of arsenic, cobalt, lithium and molybdenum, according to a recent report prepared by environmental groups using TVA’s own data. Tennessee Valley Authority

    Report: TVA’s Allen Fossil Plant in Memphis ranks No. 10 in most contaminated U.S. sites

    This story was originally published by Tennessee Lookout.

    The Tennessee Valley Authority’s coal ash dumps in Memphis rank among the worst in the nation for contamination of groundwater with cancer-causing toxins, according to a new report that relied on the power provider’s own records.

    TVA’s coal ash dumps at the now-defunct Allen Fossil Plant rank as the 10th worst contaminated sites in the country in a report released earlier this month that examined groundwater monitoring data from coal-fired plant operators, including TVA.

    TVA’s own monitoring data shows its Memphis dumps are leaking arsenic at levels nearly 300 times safe drinking water limits. Unsafe levels of boron, lead and molybdenum are also being recorded there.

    The report, prepared and published by the Environmental Integrity Project (EIP) and Earthjustice, shows that coal ash dumps at every TVA coal-fired facility across Tennessee are leaking dangerous contaminants at unsafe levels, including arsenic, cobalt, lithium, molybedenum, boron, lead and sulfate, into groundwater.

  • Still no reckoning for coal-ash polluters
    in News

    1024px Kingston plant spill swanpond tn2A TVA ash pond at Watts Bar ruptured with disastrous consequences in December 2008.  Wikipedia 

    Report contends coal plant operators are shirking responsibilities on ash cleanup

    This story was originally published by Tennessee Lookout

    NASHVILLE — In the wake of major coal ash spills from power plant containment ponds in Tennessee and into the Dan River along the North Carolina and Virginia border, the federal Environmental Protection Agency in 2015 laid out the first federal rules for managing the ash, one of the nation’s largest waste streams, and the toxins it contains.  

    But more than seven years later, few utilities and other owners responsible for the often unlined pits where billions of tons of ash leach heavy metals and other toxins into groundwater are planning comprehensive cleanups, per a report released this month by a pair of environmental groups. 

  • Public comment: Environmental group leaders say TVA makes input difficult
    in News

    Handout from TVA Listening Session Aug. 30 2022Scott Banbury with the Tennessee Chapter of the Sierra Club said a handout provided at TVA’s Aug. 30 listening session stated recordings of the meeting were not allowed; a TVA spokesperson said recordings are, in fact, allowed. Flyer provided by Scott Banbury

    Is TVA trying to gag its critics?

    This story was originally published by Tennessee Lookout.

    KNOXVILLE — While the Tennessee Valley Authority, a utility company that provides power to millions in Tennessee and other states, allows for public input into decisions, the process isn’t simple or transparent, say some regular attendees.

    Take, for instance, a recent public listening session: representatives of the Tennessee Chapter of the Sierra Club say they were told they could not record the session despite a spokesman for TVA saying the opposite.

    According to TVA spokesperson Scott Brooks, attendees are always allowed to record public meetings, provided they don’t cause a disturbance, but minutes before the session, members of the Tennessee chapter of the Sierra Club were prohibited from doing so.

  • Activists urge TVA to take advantage of historic US climate bill for energy-efficiency improvements
    in News

    TVA 1 2048x1365A hopper car on a train filled with coal to be delivered to a TVA coal-fired plant. John Partipilo/Tennessee Lookout

    Climate bill designates TVA as a potential recipient of clean energy investments and loans

    This story was originally published by Tennessee Lookout.

    KNOXVILLE  Clean-energy advocates are urging the Tennessee Valley Authority to use funds provided through the Inflation Reduction Act to deliver environmentally friendly energy to Tennessee customers. 

    The massive bill Congress passed Friday includes $370 billion for clean energy investments and listed TVA as an entity that is eligible to take advantage of clean energy credits and loans to significantly reduce the cost of energy-efficient infrastructure. 

    On Aug. 12, the Clean Up TVA Coalition, including the Sierra Club, the Southern Alliance for Clean Energy and Appalachian Voices, urged TVA to take advantage of the legislation and make funds available to its affiliated local power companies, which can then offer energy-efficient options for customers.

  • Dems pass huge climate bill assailed by some as another fossil energy sop
    in News

    5 July 2022 US Significant Climate Events Map

    Record-setting bill will fund extensive efforts to address climate change, but the sausage-making deal is decried by some as a ‘suicide pact’

    This story was originally published by Tennessee Lookout.

    WASHINGTON — The U.S. Senate, along party lines, passed a sweeping energy, health care, climate and tax package Sunday afternoon, following an overnight marathon of votes that resulted in just a handful of notable changes to the legislation.

    The 755-page bill was passed after Vice President Kamala Harris broke a 50-50 tie in the evenly divided Senate. It now heads to the House, where Democratic leaders have announced they will take it up on Friday.

    At last, we have arrived,” Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer said.  Democratic senators broke out into applause as Harris announced passage of the bill, expected to total more than $700 billion.

    Schumer, a New York Democrat, said he dedicated the measure to young Americans who have pushed and protested for the Senate to take action on climate change. 

  • Fossil-fuel pipeline in your front yard, anyone? Senate passes bill blocking local power over pipeline placement
    in News

    pipelineThis pumping station in Dickson County was the site of a 1992 gas line rupture. John Partipilo/Tennessee Lookout

    Bill eliminating local oversight of fossil-fuel infrastructure passes state Senate at behest of fuel companies, now on to House

    This story was originally published by Tennessee Lookout.

    UPDATE: The state House approved the bill March 29 with moderating amendments sought by local governments and environmental and social justice advocates.

    NASHVILLE — The Tennessee Senate passed a controversial pipeline preemption bill on Thursday in spite of concerns about the effect oil and gas pipelines could have on personal property and drinking water.

    Before passage, Sen. Ken Yager, R-Kingston, sponsor of SB2077, amended the bill to allow for wellhead protections and to align with its House counterpart. Critics still contended that with local governments lacking the ability to regulate fossil fuel infrastructure, communities could do little to protect themselves from unwanted pipelines. 

  • Tennessee Lookout: GOP legislators move to usurp even more local control with pro-pipeline bill
    in News

    GOP-led Legislature aims to ban local decisions on fossil-fuel infrastructure

    This story was originally published by Tennessee Lookout.

    Per updated TL reporting, this bill was deferred to March 15 for committee consideration.

    Memphis activist Justin Pearson spent years trying to pass legislation to protect his city’s natural drinking water, but a bill being fast tracked through the state Legislature is threatening his efforts.  

    Last week, environmental activists learned that Rep. Kevin Vaughan, R-Collierville, and Sen. Ken Yager, R-Kingston, are seeking to pass a bill aimed at removing local government control over land use zoning for fossil fuel infrastructure. 

    Both the Tennessee State House and Senate Commerce Committees will vote on HB2246 and SB2077 on Tuesday, and if the bill passes, it could be on the Legislature floor by Thursday. 

  • Part IV: Clear-cut controversy. Thoughts and prayers
    in News

    service pnp pga 09600 09690vLibrary of Congress

    Citizens and scientists weigh in on controversial TWRA logging plan

    For months, Tennessee Lookout has bird-dogged a Tennessee Wildlife Resources Agency proposal to clear at least 1,000 acres of hardwood forest in the Bridgestone Centennial Wildlife Reserve in White County to create habitat for dwindling bobwhite quail

    Hellbender Press has published most of the stories, with much appreciation to Tennessee Lookout. Most recently, the online news outlet reported that legal hurdles had been cleared to allow TWRA to proceed, at least for now, with its game-bird reintroduction plans at the expense of acres of approximately 65-year-old hardwood forest. 

    Though it was not Hellbender’s original reporting, on our end the social media response to the articles has been thoughtful and reasoned — with, of course, occasional disagreements among commenters. With permission from the posters, I’ve compiled an edited and abridged recitation of some comments, which were too good to languish in the social media ether.

  • Part III: Clear-cut controversy in the Cumberlands
    in News

    Bridgestone

    Legal opinion cuts path for TWRA forest clearing in White County’s Bridgestone wilderness area despite local opposition

    This story was originally published by Tennessee Lookout.

    A controversial plan by the Tennessee Wildlife Resources Agency officials to clearcut forest in a popular hunting, hiking and recreation area in order to create habitat for Northern bobwhite quail has gotten a legal go-ahead, despite opposition from residents and local leaders in White County, a bipartisan group of lawmakers and environmental groups.

    The 16,000-acre Bridgestone Firestone Centennial Wilderness Area, a forested area adjacent to Fall Creek Falls State Park and Virgin Falls State Natural Area, was a late 1990’s gift to the state from the tire company that came with certain strings attached, including that state officials “preserve the property predominantly in its present condition as a wilderness area.”

    The Tennessee Wildlife Federation was charged with ensuring the state honors those conditions.

    On Friday, a spokeswoman for the Tennessee Wildlife Federation confirmed that outside legal counsel hired to review the state’s clearcutting plan found it “meets the requirements” of the gift.

    “Speaking broadly as a conservation nonprofit, we have supported throughout our 75-year history the science-based, proactive management of lands to maintain or restore diverse habitats and diverse wildlife,” Kate Hill, a Tennessee Wildlife Federation spokeswoman, said via email. “The fact is savannas are an endangered habitat in the Southeast that were once common and provided essential habitat to many species across Tennessee.”

    Neither the Tennessee Wildlife Federation nor the Tennessee Wildlife Resources Agency has communicated the outcome of the legal review to local residents, who have complained for months that they have been kept in the dark and offered no meaningful opportunity to weigh in on plans to radically alter a landscape that is both beloved and central to the local economy.

  • Memphis takes a stand against convenience stores that feed health disparities
    in News
    By

    IMG 0447

    Citing a dearth of grocery stores and healthy food options, Memphis officials mull action 

    This story was originally published by Tennessee Lookout.

    “In the poorest Memphis neighborhoods, gas stations serve as the nearest and sometimes the only store with groceries for nearby communities, albeit ones offering unhealthy fast and convenience foods. The University of Memphis noted that the city’s overall poverty rate is 21.7 percent, and rates are even higher among communities of color and among children, with a child poverty rate of 35 percent.”

    In some areas of Memphis, there are more gas stations than grocery stores. While a citywide moratorium placed a hold on new gas stations, businesses are still seeking permission from City Council to open against the wishes of local communities.

    In March, City Council voted in favor of halting permitting of any new gas stations. Businesses now need to go through the Land Use Control Board of Memphis and Shelby County for permission, and their request would need final approval from City Council. 

    “It seemed like every week we were passing an ordinance to allow two or three more service stations and we didn’t  feel like we had a handle on it. We felt like that needed to calm down,” said Councilman Jeff Warren.

    At an October meeting, council members debated whether Broad Avenue needed another gas station (and convenience store). Hundreds of residents in the nearby neighborhoods signed a petition urging council members to vote against allowing another gas station in their community. 

    “We do not want nor need a gas station at this site. That would make four gas stations within a mile radius. . .I fully expect you to listen to the money, rather than the neighbors,” said one resident.

    Council members concluded the meeting without making a decision, opting to delay the vote for a month, but the response from local residents was clear: there were more than enough gas stations in communities needing other types of stores. 

    “Who in their right mind would add a fourth gas station on a street that’s a mile long?” said another resident.

    Over the span of 20 to 30 years, Memphis officials permitted gas station after gas station to open throughout the city to the point that “there’s 10 times more per population than Nashville has,” said Warren. 

    Gas service stations are a lucrative business. According to Forbes, the market relies on minimizing the distance that consumers have to travel, and competition means that at any given intersection, gas stations are often located on each corner.