The Environmental Journal of Southern Appalachia
Thursday, 16 February 2023 12:04

Infamous South Knoxville Superfund site will soon take first steps on long road to recovery

Written by

IMG 9536A sign warns against entry to the Smokey Mountain Smelters Superfund site off Maryville Pike in the Vestal community of Knoxville.  Heather Duncan Nelson/Hellbender Press

EPA plans to contain toxic waste and restore waterways; community group will offer guidance

KNOXVILLE — A crowd gathered in the South Knoxville Community Center to hear the Environmental Protection Agency’s long-awaited remediation plan for Smoky Mountain Smelting and its hazardous waste. Others tuned in via the Internet.

The meeting called by Vestal Community Organization took place Feb. 13. The EPA’s presentation and many questions focused on the former Smoky Mountain Smelting site at 1508 Maryville Pike near Montgomery Village Apartments.

Heather Duncan Nelson reported last year for Hellbender Press on the initial cleanup plans.

But citizens this week raised concerns about other contaminated former industrial properties along the same road. Vestal Community Organization plans to hold another meeting at 6 p.m. Feb. 22 to discuss and decide its position on these Maryville Pike properties.

“I was just thrilled and enamored by the way people were listening to the questions and answers,” said Eric Johnson with Vestal Community Organization, adding that he was referring both to the EPA and the citizens.

Smoky Mountain Smelting
At the meeting, EPA staff provided a handout and presentation outlining the site’s history and EPA plans.

From the 1920s through the 1960s, agricultural and chemical companies operated at the site before Smoky Mountain Smelters, also known as Rotary Furnace Inc., came to the location in 1979. 

The company melted scrap aluminum and aluminum dross together to cast the byproduct into aluminum bars. These operations continued until 1994. Even before that point, in the 1980s, the Tennessee Division of Solid Waste Management concluded that the site wasn’t suitable to be an industrial landfill. Yet the company continued to store its waste from the smelting on the site. 

EPA Remedial Project Manager Peter Johnson said the dross and saltcakes left over from the process react with water, releasing heat and ammonia gas. They leach aluminum, ammonia, chloride “and many other contaminants,” he said. Smoky Mountain Smelting’s toxins have flowed through groundwater into a tributary of Flenniken Branch. Some including Vestal community resident Cathy Scott have raised concerns about that water reaching the fishing areas at I.C. King Park and eventually the Tennessee River.

In 2010, the Smoky Mountain Smelting site ended up on the federal Superfund list due to its contaminated soil, sediments and surface water. The EPA had already started working on the site in 2008, according to information the agency gave at the meeting, removing some of the onsite waste and capping the remaining waste piles with a foot of clay and six inches of topsoil with grass planted on top.

The EPA plans to start this month and work through November on further measures, funded by recently available federal taxpayer funds from the bipartisan infrastructure bill passed at the behest of the President Joe Biden administration.

First, the EPA plans to combine the waste from the two existing waste piles into one and move some soil there too before restoring wetlands and tributary beds. Then the EPA will put a cap which includes a gas collection layer, two synthetic liners, a drainage layer and a covering of 24 inches total of soil, seed and mulch. This cap is meant to prevent storm water from reaching the waste and having it flow into the groundwater.

Another process includes putting calcium polysulfide and bacteria into groundwater to reduce contaminants and immobilize metals.

Johnson told the audience that parts of the property could become a transportation hub or a place for fixing rail cars.

“We don’t want this to remain fenced and unused,” he said of the property.

Some people in the audience, however, had their own ideas on the site’s future.

“What you’re saying is you’re making this a little better landfill,” one said. “As taxpayers with all these millions of dollars we’re putting in, why don’t we have a say on the property?”

Martin Pleasant, who told Hellbender Press he lives across a set of railroad tracks from the Smoky Mountain Smelting property, said he did not believe the county should sell the property after the EPA’s efforts but rather convert the area into a public park.

“I don’t think we’ll ever recover that from a tax sale,” he said. “I think public use has the greatest value.” When asked about whether he was concerned that children might accidentally unearth toxic material, he said any use might have that risk.

Knoxville City Council Woman Amelia Parker, who also attended the meeting in person, told Hellbender Press afterward she held similar views to Pleasant, preferring a public use. However, she said she’d prefer the waste go somewhere else.

“Ideally we would not have a landfill that we’re maintaining,” she said.

The EPA presenters at the meeting stressed the steps they would take to make sure the site’s protection stayed in place, such as preventing trees from growing their roots into the landfill and breaking the cover.

“The EPA doesn’t just walk away from these sites when there’s waste left in place,” said Rusty Kestle, Environmental Protection Agency project manager for the site.

The rest of Maryville Pike?

While Peter Johnson, Kettle and EPA coordinator Marjorie Thomas talked about the Smoky Mountain Smelting site, others had a broader focus: the other toxic areas along Maryville Pike.

Scott at the same meeting gave a presentation on these areas.

One such site was the David Witherspoon Inc. site at 1630 Maryville Pike. Scott described it as involved with sorting and recycling of “millions of pounds of scrap metal contaminated with radioactive isotopes,” chiefly uranium and thorium. This work took place, Scott said, between 1960 and 1984 for the Atomic Energy Commission which later became the Department of Energy. Other wastes she described on that site included asbestos, PCBs, heavy metals and blood bags and other medical waste. 

She also spoke of the Candoro site, also associated with the Witherspoon family but never tested for radioactivity or toxic chemicals. Dax Witherspoon is suing to rezone the site to Heavy Industrial, Scott said.

Rate this item
(3 votes)

Related items

  • Proposed Oak Ridge airport still doesn’t fly for many
    in News

    Rober Kennedy of Tennessee Valley Stellar CorporationRobert Kennedy shows a prototype drone under development by the nonprofit Tennessee Valley Stellar Corporation. He had removed the propellers and battery to make it easier to bring it inside and to avoid security and safety concerns about his intentions. He wanted to use it for show and tell, but was denied the opportunity to speak. Attendees were offered to dictate comments to a court recorder. Few were willing to stand in line and do so. Written comments may be sent until Aug. 18, 2023.  Wolf Naegeli/Hellbender Press

    Public hearing on proposed Oak Ridge airport suggests there is no easy glide path for project

    OAK RIDGE — Citizens of Oak Ridge and surrounding communities continue to debate the pros and cons of a new airport in the area. A public forum on Tuesday, Aug. 8, 2023, brought together those for and against the proposed airport to study documents and discuss the project.

    While there was an opportunity to give verbal comments to a court reporter, many decided to put comments in writing. Additional comments can be submitted by Friday, Aug. 18 via mail to FAA Memphis District Office, 2600 Thousand Oaks Blvd., Suite 2250, Memphis or by email to This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..

    The city plans to construct a 5,000-foot runway, partial parallel taxiway, and associated facilities at a location north of U.S. 58 between Perimeter and Blair roads. It’s in the Heritage Center around the former K-25 site from the Manhattan Project era

    The city of Oak Ridge government commissioned GMC to write an Environmental Assessment and the Federal Aviation Administration will review it, along with public comments to make decisions about moving forward with the airport construction. In a press release the city of Oak Ridge stated it organized the hearing to follow federal laws and policies. Other reasons for the meeting included issues such as “area wetland, streams, and ponds; archaeological and historical sites; biological issues; airport noise and social effects such as road closures and realignments; view shed and lighting impacts.”

  • Citizens continue call for TVA to adopt sustainable alternatives to coal plants
    in News

    IMG 6655Citizens are objecting to plans to replace the coal boilers at Kingston Fossil Plant with natural gas.  Ben Pounds/Hellbender Press

    Solar? Gas? Future of Kingston plant up in the air

    KINGSTON — Tennessee Valley Authority is considering whether to go with gas or solar power after it closes the infamous Kingston Fossil Plant in Tennessee.

    The plant has stood since 1955 in Roane County. The federal utility plans to close Kingston Fossil plant and is looking at ways to replace the power it generated. It’s asking the public for comments. The utility’s proposals center around replacing the power generated by the plant with either solar generation or natural gas. One option includes replacing the coal-powered plant at the site with a fossil gas plant.

    TVA recently proposed to retire three units between 2026 and 2031 and the other six units between 2027 and 2033. Ash spilled from a dike at this plant in 2008. A lawsuit was recently resolved surrounding the health damage to people working on cleaning up the spill. TVA has identified trouble with starting up and shutting down the plant for power generation and technical issues with lower boilers as the reasons for closing the plant, not the spill.

  • TWRA wants your data on Tennessee’s wild turkeys
    in News

    wild-turkey-008-Eric-Lowery.jpgAmerican wild turkey populations have recovered from historic lows. TWRA still needs help managing the modern populations.  Courtesy Eric Lowery via Tennessee Wildlife Resources Agency

    TWRA wants you to help build research on USA’s second bird

    NASHVILLE — Benjamin Franklin only joked (we think) about making the wild turkey the national bird, but this summer you can help Tennessee with research on the turkey’s national history and renaissance.

    Turkeys and bald eagles both grace the state and Southeast and have a notably parallel history of climbing from dire straits nationwide. 

    The bald eagle became the national symbol on the U.S. seal in 1782

    Declaration of Independence signer Franklin said he would have preferred a different bird. While he may have been joking, he never lobbied for it publicly. His comments in a letter to his daughter, Sarah, have become infamous.

    “For my own part I wish the bald eagle had not been chosen as the representative of our country. He is a bird of bad moral character. He does not get his living honestly. You may have seen him perched on some dead tree, where, too lazy to fish for himself, he watches the labour of the fishing hawk; and when that diligent bird has at length taken a fish, and is bearing it to his nest for the support of his mate and young ones, the bald eagle pursues him, and takes it from him … the turkey is in comparison a much more respectable bird, and withal a true original native of America.” 

  • Work is under way to clean up infamous South Knoxville Superfund site
    in News

    Screenshot 595

    EPA finally capping toxic waste at South Knoxville Superfund site

    KNOXVILLE — The Environmental Protection Agency this week began putting a protective cap on the former Smokey Mountain Smelters site to control its pollution.

    The EPA said the cap will protect nearby waterways by stopping stormwater runoff from combining with the toxic waste on site. Engineers and workers began the project the week of July 6.

    By cutting it off from the stormwater, the EPA hopes to stop toxins from flowing away either through groundwater or runoff. The site is off Maryville Pike in South Knoxville. Caleb Properties purchased two of the site’s three parcels at the Delinquent Property Tax Sale on May 16. EPA is building the cap and storing the waste in the area Caleb Properties purchased. The agency stated Caleb Properties committed to “allocating a portion of the development of the site for community benefit,” and they’ll still have to work with the EPA’s remedy for cleanup. 

    Hellbender Press has reported on the cleanup sites and environmental legacies.

  • High-profile cleanup to commence on South Knoxville Superfund site, but what about the other toxic sites?
    in News

    Smokey Mountain Smelters siteSmokey Mountain Smelters site is seen in this EPA file photo. Work has commenced on cleaning up this particular Superfund site, but South Knoxville residents are wondering about the fate of the other highly toxic sites along Maryville Pike.

    Vestal community leans into future of multiple South Knoxville Superfund sites 

    KNOXVILLE — City residents are discussing the future of the Vestal community’s toxic sites after a long history of industrial use and activism that recently led to federally funded action to clean up at least one infamous Superfund site.

    Vestal community resident Cathy Scott shared the history of each of these sites near Maryville Pike at South Knox Community Center during two Vestal Community Organization meetings related to the cleanup of multiple Superfund sites on the south side of the city.

    She said in an email to Hellbender Press that much of her information came from John Nolt, formerly of the University of Tennessee Philosophy Department and author of the essay “Injustice in the Handling of Nuclear Weapons Waste: The Case of David Witherspoon Inc.,” which is chapter three of the book “Mountains of Injustice: Social and Environmental Justice in Appalachia.”

    While the EPA is focusing on the Smokey Mountain Smelter site, Scott, Nolt and others have discussed other properties and their effects on nearby watersheds. The sites are all connected to the Witherspoon family. They are at are at 1508 Maryville Pike; 1630 Maryville Pike and adjacent land; 901 Maryville Pike and 4430 Candoro Ave. The meetings took place Feb. 13 and 22.

    “It was a phenomenal accomplishment of community collaboration,” Eric Johnson, president of Vestal Community Organization, said of the two meetings. 

  • Whiskey business: Help UT save white oaks for your liquor drinks
    in News

    images 2 

    UT forestry efforts benefit whiskey and ecological chasers

    KNOXVILLE — Volunteers, distilleries and two universities came together this fall to collect white oak acorns to ensure the survival of the species for commercial and ecological purposes.

    It was a key part of a conservation effort started by distilleries worried about the future of oak barrels and casks used to age whiskey and bourbon.

    It’s about more than that though, as white oaks have many uses not just for people but for an estimated 2,000 other species, including bats, birds, turkeys, deer, rabbits and hundreds of butterflies and moths. But because the trees are slow to grow, they may be at risk, especially as the region grapples with the uncertain outcomes of climate change.

  • Wither wisteria: ‘People care about our land’
    in News

    IMG 4106Anne Child removes invasive exotic plants during a recent Tennessee Citizens for Wilderness Planning event to mark National Public Lands Day at TVA’s Worthington Cemetery in Oak Ridge. Ben Pounds/Hellbender Press

    Citizens pay it back on Public Lands Day in Oak Ridge, Smokies and beyond

    OAK RIDGE — Rain drizzled as volunteers dug and clipped plants in woods around an old cemetery turned science lab.

    It was a Public Lands Day event at Tennessee Valley Authority Worthington Cemetery Ecological Study area in Oak Ridge near Melton Hill Lake. Tennessee Citizens for Wilderness Planning, an environmental organization based in Oak Ridge, led the Sept. 24 work party in support of American public lands.

    Other events were held throughout the country to mark the date (including Great Smoky Mountains National Park), which has proven itself to be the most productive day of the year for citizen sweat equity in public lands.

  • In throwback to early naturalist techniques, Big Camera! helps us picture plants under the sun
    in News

    big cameraDonna Moore and Anna Lawrence are pictured at a Big Camera! event in May at Ijams Nature Center in South Knoxville. Ben Pounds/Hellbender PressLessons in early and enduring photo techniques are an organic way to spread the arts and cultivate love of nature

    KNOXVILLE — Donna Moore and Anna Lawrence showed people how to take photos with the sun.

    The method, demonstrated this spring at Ijams Nature Center, involved putting one or more leaves on photo paper and spraying it with two sprays. One spray contained lemon and water. The other contained water with vinegar.

    Children then placed these leaves on wet photo paper in the sun. The sun’s light gives a permanent impression of the leaf on the paper.

  • Knoxville kids go beast mode at new natural playscape

    ijams kid playscapeA child defends an elaborate stick fort at Ijams Natural Playscape, which opened this week at the South Knoxville nature center.  Ijams Nature Center

    New Ijams playground reconnects kids with neighborhood woods, forts and creeks of yore

    KNOXVILLE — Ijams Nature Center officially opened a portal into pure childhood beast mode this week.

    The Ijams Nature Playscape at Grayson Subaru Preserve is specifically designed for young children to play in a creek, climb hills, dig, build, crawl and engage with nature in an organic, unstructured way. The new space features a large nest, tunnels, log steps and different rooms to play in.

    “For generations, many of us had the opportunity to roam and play in the woods, empty lots and fields that surrounded our homes and neighborhoods,” Ijams Executive Director Amber Parker said. “We remember the freedom we had to use our imagination, test ourselves and become a part of the natural landscape, at least until we were called home for dinner.”

  • Infrastructure funding to cover South Knoxville Superfund site cleanup
    in News

    Smokey Mountain Smelters siteAerial view (ca. 2002) of Smokey Mountain Smelters Superfund site, located between two rail lines. At left is the overpass of Maryville Pike, at right a section of Knox County Development Corporation’s Montgomery Village Apartments. The large smelter hall and a few of the apartment buildings have since been removed.  Image from TN Dept. of Health

    Knoxville’s most polluted former industrial site is slated for a massive cleanup soon thanks to funding from the bipartisan infrastructure bill Congress recently passed. The Smokey Mountain Smelters site in Vestal has spent more than a decade on the National Priorities List, commonly called the “Superfund” list, of the most contaminated properties in the U.S. 

    The work could start within just a few months, said Rusty Kestle, Environmental Protection Agency project manager for the site. He said it’s the top priority in the Southeast for the infrastructure funding because it’s among the most affordable and ready for action.