The Environmental Journal of Southern Appalachia
Wednesday, 10 August 2022 12:29

Monarch butterflies, an ephemeral but regular glimpse of beauty, are fluttering toward extinction

Written by

 Bales Monarch on coneflowerA monarch butterfly, recently declared endangered despite decades of conservation, is seen atop a coneflower. Stephen Lyn Bales

Dramatic monarch declines mean the bell tolls for we

KNOXVILLE — Monarch butterflies are ephemeral by nature. The orange and black dalliances that flitter through our lives, our yards, and our countryside like motes of dust are here one minute and gone the next. We pause for a few seconds to watch the “flutter-bys” and then move on.

For about all of the Lepidopteran family, where they come from, where they go, their raison d'être, we don’t ask. They are winged wisps that pass through our busy lives. But that is not true with this orange and black butterfly, named to honor King William III of England, the Prince of Orange. But two people did ask.

Norah and Fred Urquhart lived in Southern Canada and in the late 1930s they noticed that the monarch butterflies seemed to all be fluttering south this time of the year. Could they possibly be migrating and if so, where did they go? The notion that a butterfly might migrate south for the winter seemed hard to fathom. Yes, broad-winged hawks migrate. But a flimsy butterfly?

After creating a protocol that included netting a monarch and attaching a small sticker with an identification number and with the help of hundreds of volunteers, what the Urquharts discovered after four decades of research was mind-blowing, and rocked the world of natural history.

Monarch migration made headlines

The announcement was showcased in National Geographic magazine in August 1976. Urquhart himself wrote the article, which detailed how every year between August and early November monarch butterflies in the east migrate to the Sierra Madre Mountains of Mexico. The world read in disbelief. I still have that issue with Mexican naturalist Catalina Aguado on the cover surrounded by thousands of orange and black monarchs, dalliances no more.

It’s an astonishing story often taught in elementary schools today.  You can ask a group of kids, “Does anyone know where monarchs go in winter?” And one or more will answer “To Mexico!” The epic odyssey of a half-gram butterfly (they weigh less than a postage stamp) has been retold often on PBS. Most grandly, it’s the subject of a 2012 documentary titled Flight of the Butterflies. The 3D IMAX film presents their long migration in all of its breathtaking glory, including scenes of thousands of monarchs clinging to the Mexican trees in winter.

Because of their panache, monarchs have perhaps been studied more than any other insect. There are two populations in North America. Our eastern population migrates from as far as southern Canada to Mexico every year. West of the Rockies, the population migrates to Southern California. Monarchs produce four generations a year, the ones that migrate south for the winter are the great-grand offspring of the monarchs that spent their winters there the year before.    

Monarch data is still being collected. Locally, Great Smoky Mountains Institute at Tremont nets and tags monarchs annually in a program of shared community science that originated in 1998 with naturalist Wanda DeWaard.

This feel-good story has curdled over a remarkably short period of time. How do you conduct a census of an insect population? Quickly. Go outside and count all the swamp cicadas you can find. Impossible. Fortunately, because all living North American monarchs overwinter in only two locations, it is possible to get a rough estimate. And those numbers have been declining at more alarming rates with each passing year.

The Xerces Society tallies the western population in the forested groves of California, including Santa Cruz, Fremont, Pismon Beach and several places in Monterey, Riverside and Los Angeles counties.

In 1997 their estimate was 1.26 million monarchs. By 2008, that number had dropped to roughly 150,000. And by 2019, only 29,418 wintering monarchs were recorded, representing a drop of 98 percent in just 22 years.  A similar decline in the eastern population has also been reported, with an overall decline of more than 80 percent.

Why such a dramatic decline?

A 2021 study by Michigan State University on the declines cited the same lethal cocktail we have been hearing about since the 1970s: habitat loss, climate change, pesticide and herbicide use. The steepest decline between 1994 and 2003 coincides with the widespread increase of herbicides that kill the plants the monarchs depend on, such as milkweed.  

Widespread pesticide use kills insects and the orange and black dalliances are most certainly insects. While from 2004 to 2018, the breeding-season weather was nearly seven times more impactful than the other causes of decline. Has anyone noticed our fluctuating weather? With climate change the delicate butterfly is a lot like us. They like it hot but not too hot, dry but not too dry and wet but not too wet.

Finally, on July 21, 2022, the monarch butterfly was placed on the Endangered Species List by the International Union of the Conservation of Nature.

Why should we care? Monarchs are glamorous environmental indicators. They are also pollinators. If this can happen to a beloved species that has been carefully watched, what about the other 17,500 butterfly species on the planet? It is estimated that 90 percent of flowering plants will disappear with the loss of butterflies and other insects that pollinate them.

We simply do not have to ask, “For whom the bell tolls?” It tolls for we.     

Rate this item
(2 votes)

Related items

  • Appalachian trout in trouble as temps rise, storms rage
    in News

    trout_bradley.jpg.webpMichael Bradley, a fly-fishing guide, on Raven Fork in the Oconaluftee area of the Great Smoky Mountains.  U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

    Climate change could steal your fish

    Dan Chapman is a public affairs specialist for the Southeast Region of U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.

    CHEROKEE — The mountains of the Southern Appalachians were scraped clean a century ago. Headwater ecology changed as the canopy of trees disappeared that was shading the streams from all but the noonday sun. Rainstorms pushed dirt and rocks into the water muddying the feeding and breeding grounds of fish, amphibians and insects. 

    Lower down the mountain, newly cut pastures edged right up to the creeks while cows mucked up the once-pristine waters. Invasive bugs killed hemlocks, ash and other shade-giving trees. Pipes, culverts and dams blockaded streams and kept animals from cooler water. 

    The trout never had a chance.

    Now they face an even more insidious foe — climate change. 

  • Butterfly release scratched at UT Arboretum festival after pushback on ecological wisdom
    in News

    Lydia_at_Butterfly_Festival.jpgCome join the fun at the annual UT Arboretum Society Butterfly Festival from 10 a.m to 1 p.m on September 9 at the UT Forest Resources AgResearch and Education Center and Arboretum. The event will include educational activities about protecting these pollinators.  Photo courtesy University of Tennessee Institute of Agriculture

    UT grounds planned butterfly release but festival will fly

    OAK RIDGE — The University of Tennessee Arboretum canceled a planned release of painted butterflies originally scheduled for its upcoming annual butterfly festival, but the pollinator-positive educational event will go on to the joy of families and nature enthusiasts across East Tennessee.

    “While the fun-filled and educational event is still scheduled for Sept. 9, a mass release of painted lady butterflies is no longer scheduled as part of the event,” according to the UT Arboretum Society.

    The 8th annual festival will occur from 10 a.m. to 1 p.m. at the UT Forest Resources AgResearch and Education Center and Arboretum, 901 S. Illinois Avenue, Oak Ridge. Plenty of activities will provide educational opportunities for the public to learn how we can all protect our pollinators, according to the UT Institute of Agriculture.

    “The butterfly species previously planned for release at the festival was the painted lady, Vanessa carduii. Butterfly releases have been held at past festivals with the intention that the more people understand an organism, the more they are inspired to help protect it. Though there has not been definitive scientific research about the impact of painted lady butterfly releases, the UT Arboretum Society has decided to join many other scientific organizations, such as the North American Butterfly Association and the Smithsonian Institute, in not promoting this practice,” according to a release.

  • Bees are the bees knees!

    image0.jpegCynthia Maples, the head beekeeper at Zoo Knoxville, checks out her buzzing charges. JJ Stambaugh

    With no clear cause, after two decades beekeepers across North America report losing up to 90 percent of their hives.

    Although the alarming losses of the 2006-7 season have not repeated, since then, experts consistently track higher than normal winter losses among honeybee colonies, according to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).

    A survey by the University of Maryland University of Maryland found 40% of US honeybee colonies died between April 2018 and April 2019.

    While most Americans associate the insects with one of humankind’s oldest sweet treats - honey - they might not realize honeybees are actually an invasive species that can end up competing for resources with indigenous “pollinators” such as bumblebees. 

    “Worldwide, there are over 20,000 species of bees,” said Cynthia Maples, the lead beekeeper and apiarist at Zoo Knoxville. “About 265 of those are bumble bees. In North America, there are 46 bumblebee species. In the southeast, we have about 15 bumble species with at least six of those in decline.”

    Maples explained all bees are part of the order Hymenoptera, which also includes ants and wasps.

    “Native pollinators would classify as those species naturally occurring in a particular area, not introduced. Honeybees are technically an invasive species to North America. They were brought over from Europe by humans,” she said.

    “In the past few years the narrative has made a switch from keeping honeybees to help native pollinators to the realization that honeybees may be stealing resources from native pollinators,” she continued. “Honeybees are still very important as agricultural pollinators, but protecting native pollinators is also very important.”

    While Maples doesn’t know if local bee populations are on the ropes, she said the Xerces Society for Invertebrate Conservation (an international nonprofit group) has formed regional “community science groups” as part of a widespread effort to track bumblebee species. 

    “It’s really hard to say specifically if there has been a decline in local insect populations since insects are very difficult to track,” she said. “I took part in the training for the southeast bumble bee atlas earlier this year. The hope is that this atlas will give scientists a better idea of population numbers.”

    It’s important that scientists understand any threats to the health of the world’s bee populations as the insects are vital to humankind’s ability to survive.

    Bees — both domesticated and wild — are responsible for pollinating 71 of the 100 crop species that provide 90 percent of the global food supply, according to experts from greentumble.

    Without bees, for instance, there would be no apples, avocados, onions, cucumbers, oranges or almonds. 

    “Pollination is defined as the act of transferring pollen grains from the male anther of a flower to the female stigma,” Maples explained. “When bees go from flower to flower collecting pollen, they are also depositing pollen grains onto the flowers, thus pollinating them. Not all plants rely on insects to reproduce; for example, some are wind pollinated.”

    “The bees benefit because nectar and pollen are their food source. Nectar is an energy source and pollen is a protein source for them. Many agricultural plants are pollinated by bees, hence their importance for us. Roughly one in three bites of food are pollinated by bees, plus another 25 percent of animal feed stuffs. Almonds are 100 percent honeybee pollinated.”

    It’s not entirely clear why bee populations appear to be shrinking, but Maples said there’s no shortage of possible explanations.

    “As with many species in decline, there are a number of reasons behind it,” she said. “Habitat loss is a big one. Our culture has taught us that we should have pristine lawns without ‘weeds,’ but letting your yard — even in part — grow wild would be a huge step in creating more resources for pollinators. Dandelions and clover can be a haven for pollinators.”

    Poisons used to control unwanted animals and insects are another factor. 

    “Pesticides have a huge impact as well, especially though containing neonicotinoids,” she said. “Pesticides rarely distinguish between beneficial invertebrates and those that cause harm.”

    This summer’s historic heatwaves in the Northern Hemisphere may also be playing a role, but Maples cautioned that it’s too early to know for certain what the impact is. 

    “Climate change may also be playing a role,” she explained. “It isn’t clear if bumblebees are adapting to changing temperatures within their normal ranges.” 

    Those interested in helping researchers to track bee populations can go to Xerces and learn about taking part in one of the organization’s community science groups.

  • Green floater mussels are somewhat safe here but not elsewhere
    in News

    Green floater mussel Ryan Hagerty USFW A green floater mussel (Lasmigona subviridis).  Ryan Hagerty/USFWS

    WASHINGTON, D.C. — The green floater, a freshwater mussel native to the waters of Southern Appalachia, is now formally considered at risk of extinction due to the loss and fragmentation of its aquatic habitat. 

    The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service determined the green floater, historically found in 10 eastern U.S. states, is likely to become endangered due to existing and emerging threats. The service is proposing to list the mussel as threatened under the Endangered Species Act

    The green floater is still found in its native range in North Carolina, Tennessee, Virginia and West Virginia. It is considered locally extinct in Alabama and Georgia. 

    While the species has strongholds in places, green floaters are rare in nearly 80 percent of the watersheds where they naturally occur. More than 75 percent of the nation’s native freshwater mussel species are endangered or threatened, considered to be of special conservation concern, or presumed extinct, according to USWFS.

  • Here’s an updated summer primer for the end of the world as we know it
    in News

    halloween sun 2014 2kThe Earth’s sun is seen in this NASA image. Scientists said July might be the hottest month in 100,000 years.  

    The global heat wave of July 2023 has spared Southern Appalachia. So far.

    KNOXVILLE July 2023 has so far offered a scary look at global climate change around the world, and the month is already one for the record books.

    This month will likely end up being the hottest July on record, globally speaking. That comes after quantitative conclusions from multiple scientists that the past week was, globally, the warmest in 100,000 years.

    The Southern Appalachians have generally been spared from the heat settling on vast portions of the country and world, but that will soon change. The National Weather Service predicts higher than average temperatures flirting with 100 degrees in the Tennessee Valley next week. Record-breaking temperatures are possible. The average high temperature for July in Knoxville is 87 degrees.

  • TWRA wants your data on Tennessee’s wild turkeys
    in News

    wild-turkey-008-Eric-Lowery.jpgAmerican wild turkey populations have recovered from historic lows. TWRA still needs help managing the modern populations.  Courtesy Eric Lowery via Tennessee Wildlife Resources Agency

    TWRA wants you to help build research on USA’s second bird

    NASHVILLE — Benjamin Franklin only joked (we think) about making the wild turkey the national bird, but this summer you can help Tennessee with research on the turkey’s national history and renaissance.

    Turkeys and bald eagles both grace the state and Southeast and have a notably parallel history of climbing from dire straits nationwide. 

    The bald eagle became the national symbol on the U.S. seal in 1782

    Declaration of Independence signer Franklin said he would have preferred a different bird. While he may have been joking, he never lobbied for it publicly. His comments in a letter to his daughter, Sarah, have become infamous.

    “For my own part I wish the bald eagle had not been chosen as the representative of our country. He is a bird of bad moral character. He does not get his living honestly. You may have seen him perched on some dead tree, where, too lazy to fish for himself, he watches the labour of the fishing hawk; and when that diligent bird has at length taken a fish, and is bearing it to his nest for the support of his mate and young ones, the bald eagle pursues him, and takes it from him … the turkey is in comparison a much more respectable bird, and withal a true original native of America.” 

  • Tennessee Aquarium wants to up the pollination game
    in News

    Pollinator Pathway signPollinator Pathway signs on the Tennessee Aquarium Plaza in Chattanooga lead guests on a self-guided tour highlighting native plants, pollinator behaviors, and unusual pollinators. Courtesy Tennessee Aquarium

    TDOT joins with Tennessee Aquarium to pollinate our pathways

    CHATTANOOGA — With their distinctive orange and black patterns, gossamer wings and harrowing 3,000-mile migrations, few insects are as charismatic or beloved as the monarch butterfly. 

    Just imagine how tragic it would be if they disappeared.

    So it was with alarm in 2022 that the world received news that the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) had declared the monarch an endangered species, citing population numbers that had fallen 80 percent since the 1980s. 

    Similar anxiety met reports in the mid-2000s of colony collapse disorder. This sudden phenomenon dramatically imperiled the survival of European honey bees, whose activity directly or indirectly affects roughly one of every three bites of food we eat, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture.

    Pollinators are undoubtedly critically important to plants and humans alike, whether they’re investigating our Irises, calling on our Columbine, or buzzing our Blueberry bushes. This week, June 19-25, the world celebrates Pollinator Week, which recognizes the wondrous, vital contributions of butterflies, bees, moths, bats, and other pollinators.

  • To critics’ dismay, TVA plans to replace coal with natural gas. The utility also plans to double its solar supply.
    in News


    Citizens call on TVA to stop passing gas

    KNOXVILLE — The Tennessee Valley Authority in coming years plans to add both natural gas and solar plants to its portfolio to meet what it says are rising energy demands.

    TVA’s Board of Directors laid out the federal utility’s plan in a meeting at Norris Middle School in May. Environmentalists at a previous hearing criticized the utility’s focus on natural gas rather than renewables or other measures. Other people, largely tied to local power providers, argued that a switch to renewable energy would be unreliable.

    TVA showed a map in a press release following the meeting, showing four proposed natural gas plants and two proposed solar plants. Two of those natural gas plants would be in Tennessee while the other two are planned for Alabama and Kentucky. It stated these new plants will total 3,800 megawatts. It also spoke of its System Operations Center, set to open in fall 2024 in Georgetown to manage the utility’s grid. TVA also stated a desire to research nuclear technologies.

    “Our region is experiencing growth at six times the national average, which means we must invest in our current power system and build new generation so we can continue meeting our region’s demand,” said TVA president and CEO Jeff Lyash.

    Several citizens criticized TVA’s focus on natural gas plants and new pipelines at the listening session May 9. Among them was Clinton resident and activist John Todd Waterman.

  • Rocking chair rebellion: Older Americans help drive climate activism
    in News

    Third Act ROCKING CHAIRSPhoto courtesy of Third Act via The Revelator

    As their twilight approaches, elders supercharge climate action on behalf of future generations 

    This story was originally published by The Revelator. Eduardo Garcia is a New York-based climate journalist. A native of Spain, he has written about climate solutions for Thomson Reuters, The New York Times, Treehugger and Slate. He is the author of Things You Can Do: How to Fight Climate Change and Reduce Waste, an illustrated book about reducing personal carbon footprints.

    Thousands of senior Americans took to the streets in March in 30 states to demand that the country’s major banks divest from fossil fuels.

    This “rocking chair rebellion” — organized by Third Act, a fast-growing climate action group focused on older Americans — shows that Baby Boomers are becoming a new force in the climate movement.

    Third Act cofounder Bill McKibben, who joined a Washington, D.C., protest, says it’s unfair to put all the weight of climate activism on the shoulders of young people. It’s time for older Americans to take a central role.

    “Young people don’t have the structural power necessary to make changes,” McKibben tells The Revelator. “But old people do. There are 70 million Americans over the age of 60. Many of us vote, we’re politically engaged, and have a lot of financial resources. So if you want to press either the political system or the financial system, older people are a useful group to have.”

  • Mad about saffron: Cardinals of color fly through Appalachian winter
    in News

    Reddick Yellow CardinalA rare yellow cardinal is seen at a residence in Roane County this winter.  Catherine Reddick

    As yellow cardinals proliferate, are we watching evolution unfold in real time?

    HARRIMAN — During the pandemic, when isolating at home became a necessity, birdwatching and bird feeders soared in popularity. Watching our avian friends come and go is entertaining, and sometimes quite surprising.

    When it comes to songbirds, especially at this time of year, the northern cardinal is perhaps the most recognized and beloved.

    It is the state bird of no less than seven states: Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, North Carolina, Ohio, Virginia and West Virginia.

    It’s also the nickname of more sports teams than any other icon. There are the St. Louis Cardinals in baseball, and the Arizona Cardinals in professional football. In the NCAA, there are the Louisville Cardinals and 17 other colleges that sport the red mascot, as well as a gaggle of high school teams across the country.

    Since we were children, we have all known what a male northern cardinal looks like. He’s bright red. Right? Yes, unless he’s bright yellow!

    Finding a golden treasure usually requires a long arduous quest through terra incognito.