The Environmental Journal of Southern Appalachia

Court finds TVA contractor potentially liable for Kingston coal-ash cleanup injuries and deaths

Written by

coalash tvaspill dotgriffithOn Dec. 23, 2008, a massive dam at the Kingston coal-fired power plant in Harriman, Tenn., ruptured and spilled 1.1 billion gallons of coal ash into the Clinch and Emory rivers. Appalachian Voices teamed up with Southwings to take pictures from the air and launched two separate missions by water to test the river and fish for pollutants as a result of the spill.  Appalachian Voices

Contractor that cleaned up infamous TVA ash spill not immune from responsibility for alleged unsafe worksite

This story was originally published by Tennessee Lookout.

CINCINNATI — A federal appellate court last week struck down a last-ditch appeal by a Tennessee Valley Authority contractor accused in the mass poisoning by radioactive coal ash waste of the utility’s Kingston disaster workforce.

The 6th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals ruled Jacobs Engineering Inc. cannot ride the coattails of TVA governmental immunity because TVA itself would not have been immune from liability had sickened workers chosen to sue the utility.

“Jacobs concedes that it is immune from suit only if the TVA is immune,” the opinion stated. “As analyzed … above, we conclude that the TVA would not have been immune from suit … Jacobs cannot benefit from derivative immunity if the TVA itself is not immune.”

The ruling comes more than 13 years after a pit filled with millions of tons of coal ash — a toxic stew of radioactive metals and dangerous toxins left over when TVA burns coal to produce electricity ­— gave way at TVA’s Kingston Fossil Plant in Roane County in December 2008 and more than eight years after disaster workers sued Jacobs, TVA’s clean-up contractor.

The 6th Circuit ruling affirms an earlier decision by U.S. District Court Judge Tom Varlan in the workers’ case and puts sickened workers one step closer to trials at which damages could be awarded. Since the spill, more than 50 workers are dead and more than 200 sick, death certificates and court records show.

Both Jacobs Engineering and TVA have denied wrongdoing, but a federal jury in 2018 ruled Jacobs breached both its contract with TVA and its duty to protect disaster clean-up workers. That verdict set the stage for workers to seek damages. Jacobs, though, has been appealing various aspects of Varlan’s handling of the case ever since, losing at every turn so far.

The road to decision

TVA has known for decades its coal ash was radioactive and full of dangerous heavy metals and toxins but publicly asserted the toxic stuff was no more dangerous than dirt when 7.3 million tons of it smothered 300 acres and polluted public drinking water sources in Kingston after the spill.

After a tipster in February 2009 alerted the Occupational Safety and Health Administration to the danger the radioactive waste posed the disaster workforce, TVA claimed — falsely — that workers had been provided respiratory and skin protection immediately after the spill but no longer needed the gear.

OSHA never followed up and, as revealed in a Tennessee Lookout investigation, destroyed TVA’s false report and all other records related to the radiation complaint after workers sued Jacobs in 2013.

Immediately after the OSHA radiation complaint was filed, the utility struck a secret deal with Jacobs to cover the contractor’s legal bills for any coal ash related illnesses and deaths.

Jacobs would go on to falsely assure the Kingston workers that coal ash was safe enough to eat daily. Workers were never told that coal ash was radioactive or that it contained other toxins, such as arsenic, cobalt, beryllium and lithium, known to be dangerous, records show.

When the Kingston workers began suffering ailments linked to the dangerous ingredients in coal ash and sought protective gear, including dust masks, managers with both TVA and Jacobs refused their requests and threatened to fire them if they persisted in seeking protection, trial testimony, depositions and TVA’s own records show.

Jacobs’ safety manager Tom Bock has since admitted in court testimony that he ordered boxes of dust masks kept on the site to be destroyed so workers could not use them.

A handful of workers later used cell phones to capture secret footage of Jacobs’ staffers appearing to tamper with testing designed to determine the threat level workers faced and a Jacobs’ supervisor telling a worker he would be “hanging yourself with your own cock” if the worker pushed for respiratory protection.

Five years into the clean-up operation, more than two dozen workers filed suit against Jacobs in U.S. District Court, because TVA was then considered immune from litigation because of its status as a quasi-governmental agency.

Jacobs, records show, invoked its secret indemnity agreement and demanded TVA pay its bills if the workers’ suit was successful. TVA won’t say if the utility — and, by extension, ratepayers — is honoring that agreement.

But less than a year after workers won a favorable verdict against Jacobs, the U.S. Supreme Court dropped a legal bomb in an unrelated case — TVA, the high court said, does not enjoy carte blanche immunity, especially when its “commercial” business of producing and selling electricity is involved.

TVA: We’re still immune

That 2019 decision, in which the high court stripped TVA of immunity in the death of a fisherman beheaded by a power line the utility was raising up from the water, led to Jacobs’ latest appeal.

Jacobs insisted the high court’s ruling still allowed immunity for TVA in cases in which the utility was carrying out “governmental” functions — as opposed to purely commercial activities — and the Kingston disaster clean-up was a part of those “governmental” functions.

And, according to the firm’s argument, if TVA would still be immune from liability in the Kingston workers’ case under the high court’s 2019 ruling, so, too, would Jacobs.

Varlan, the U.S. District judge, disagreed with the firm but allowed Jacobs to seek an emergency appeal with the 6th Circuit. In a rare move, the 6th Circuit asked TVA to weigh in.

TVA responded in April, arguing the utility remains immune in the Kingston case because TVA was acting in its governmental role as “lead federal agency” over the clean up.

In its Wednesday ruling, the 6th Circuit disagreed.

“We are not persuaded by the TVA’s argument,” the judges wrote. “(The workers) have not based their claims on the inadequacy of (TVA’s plan for worker safety at the site). The suit is instead based on Jacobs’ alleged failures to comply with the plan’s provisions.”

The court also rejected claims by Jacobs that the denial of immunity for TVA contractors would “gravely interfere” with the utility’s ability to recruit firms to carry out work on behalf of TVA.

“Jacobs argues that the TVA will struggle to find government contractors in the future if the court does not consider Jacobs immune because those contractors could be liable for significant tort damages,” the court opinion stated.

“The question that Jacobs presents is whether contractors will refuse to work with the TVA in the future because they might be held liable for significant damages,” the opinion continued. “Given that this argument is predicated on speculation as to how future contractors might analyze risk, and given that Jacobs cites no caselaw to support it, we do not find the argument persuasive.”

Although Wednesday’s opinion represents a win for Kingston workers, they still face another legal hurdle before trials on damages can be set. Jacobs has asked the Tennessee Supreme Court to consider whether a state law involving silica dust – one of 26 dangerous ingredients in coal ash – would bar some workers from collecting damages. The state Supreme Court will hear arguments on that issue in June.

 

Rate this item
(0 votes)

Related items

  • Wither wisteria: ‘People care about our land’
    in News

    IMG 4106Anne Child removes invasive exotic plants during a recent Tennessee Citizens for Wilderness Planning event to mark National Public Lands Day at TVA’s Worthington Cemetery in Oak Ridge. Ben Pounds/Hellbender Press

    Citizens pay it back on Public Lands Day in Oak Ridge, Smokies and beyond

    OAK RIDGE — Rain drizzled as volunteers dug and clipped plants in woods around an old cemetery turned science lab.

    It was a Public Lands Day event at Tennessee Valley Authority Worthington Cemetery Ecological Study area in Oak Ridge near Melton Hill Lake. Tennessee Citizens for Wilderness Planning, an environmental organization based in Oak Ridge, led the Sept. 24 work party in support of American public lands.

    Other events were held throughout the country to mark the date (including Great Smoky Mountains National Park), which has proven itself to be the most productive day of the year for citizen sweat equity in public lands.

  • SACE released its annual utility decarbonization tracking report, and it’s not pretty
    in News

    methane leaksBloomberg reports that methane leaks from the natural gas sector may be far worse than estimated by the EPA. While replacing coal-fired power plants with natural gas ones reduces air pollution it may not help at all with climate change because methane is 30 times more effective as a greenhouse gas than CO2.  Image source: Kayrros SAS

    Report: Many utilities are not reducing carbon emissions despite public assurances to the contrary

    KNOXVILLE — Global greenhouse gas emissions must peak by 2025 and experience rapid and deep reductions to avoid a potentially catastrophic future, according to a new analysis by air-quality and climate advocates. Emissions must reach net zero by the early 2050s to limit warming to 1.5 degrees (C) in order to avoid the worst impacts of the climate crisis.

    Many utilities and municipalities have acknowledged this dynamic, but the Southern Alliance for Clean Energy s fourth annual “Tracking Decarbonization in the Southeast" report highlights that current utility resource plans are not in line with this overarching target. Obstacles to getting utilities on track that are discussed in our report include: increasing reliance on fossil gas, underutilizing energy efficiency, and placing limitations on popular technologies such as rooftop solar. There’s still a lot of work to do before any Southeast utility is on track to decarbonize.

  • Infrastructure funding to cover South Knoxville Superfund site cleanup
    in News

    Smokey Mountain Smelters siteAerial view (ca. 2002) of Smokey Mountain Smelters Superfund site, located between two rail lines. At left is the overpass of Maryville Pike, at right a section of Knox County Development Corporation’s Montgomery Village Apartments. The large smelter hall and a few of the apartment buildings have since been removed.  Image from TN Dept. of Health

    Knoxville’s most polluted former industrial site is slated for a massive cleanup soon thanks to funding from the bipartisan infrastructure bill Congress recently passed. The Smokey Mountain Smelters site in Vestal has spent more than a decade on the National Priorities List, commonly called the “Superfund” list, of the most contaminated properties in the U.S. 

    The work could start within just a few months, said Rusty Kestle, Environmental Protection Agency project manager for the site. He said it’s the top priority in the Southeast for the infrastructure funding because it’s among the most affordable and ready for action.

  • SACE works to keep us all warm this winter

    This is a submission from the Southern Alliance for Clean Energy.

    After public advocacy from Knoxville community members, the KUB board passed a resolution that will deliver $5 million for emergency bill assistance to benefit those most in need, and an additional $1 million for weatherization to improve the comfort of people’s homes while lowering their bills by increasing energy efficiency. These funds are part of a pandemic relief credit from TVA.

    KUB staff proposed a resolution in October that would have allocated $1.3 million of the total $7.3 million TVA pandemic recovery credit toward payment of debt owed by KUB customers, and the remaining $6 million would be distributed as a monthly bill credit for all residential and small business KUB customers. This would have resulted in an average savings of $17 over 12 months, or about $1.40 per month for all KUB customers, regardless of their level of need for pandemic relief. 

    Knoxville Water and Energy for All (KWEA), a coalition which SACE is a part of, circulated a petition asking that KUB instead forgive all debt owed by KUB customers, and then use the remaining funds to assist households who were struggling to pay their KUB bills. KWEA delivered nearly 200 petition signatures, and the KUB board asked that the resolution be amended. 

    As a result of our coalition’s advocacy, the KUB board allocated not only the originally proposed $1.3 million for debt relief, but also the remaining $6 million for customers in need. 

    While KUB did not pledge to forgive all debt, this is certainly a major win for the community.

    The KUB Board’s decision to reallocate funds demonstrates the power of our community speaking up to advocate for ourselves and our neighbors. 

  • Lunker sturgeon are out there again

    WBIR: Holston River sturgeon surging

    The population of lake sturgeon, a survivor since the Cretaceous Era that barely escaped the ravages of modern dams and reservoirs, is on the upswing in the Holston River and other branches and tributaries of the Tennessee River system. The last record of the fish in the valley before restoration efforts began is about 1960, according to WBIR.

    Significantly older fish were identified during a recent inventory of sturgeon, giving hope that some fish were closing in on reproductive maturity. The gradual recovery is largely the result of Tennessee Wildlife Resources Agency and Tennessee Valley Authority restoration efforts, WBIR reports.

    “It makes our valley richer; that fish is supposed to be here,” one researcher told WBIR about the significance of the so-far successful restoration of native sturgeon habitats.

  • Get involved: Protestors lock arms to demand TVA swear off fossil fuels for good
    in Air

    3D2A2F6C B919 4295 B244 36D48A4BF9BD 1 105 cProtestors chant and wave signs urging TVA to commit to a fossil fuel-free future during a protest in downtown Knoxville this summer. Courtesy Amy Rawe/Southern Alliance for Clean Energy

    Activists will demand TVA allow public comments during a protest planned for Wednesday morning outside TVA HQ in downtown Knoxville

    Knoxville clean-air activists plan another protest  Wednesday outside of Tennessee Valley Authority headquarters to demand a return to public-comment periods and a commitment the huge utility won’t rely on fossil-fuel energy sources in the future.

    “Public input is critical right now, while TVA is considering building new, large fossil gas power plants and pipelines, even though they would be contrary to our need to cut greenhouse gas emissions in half by 2030,” said protest organizer Brady Watson of Southern Alliance for Clean EnergyStatewide Organizing for Community Empowerment is also coordinating the protest.

  • TVA project manager pleads guilty to falsifying reports

     

    Hard Knox Wire: Failure to disclose financial conflicts could put TVA manager in prison

    A former senior project manager at the Tennessee Valley Authority could spend up to five years in federal prison after he admitted to falsifying financial disclosure reports over several years.

    TVA is the largest public electricity provider in the nation and is in the midst of a fraught effort to lessen its dependence on fossil fuels and reduce its carbon output.

    James Christopher “Chris” Jenkins, 60, of Chattanooga, entered a guilty plea on Friday to one count of making a false official statement, according to a spokesperson from the U.S. Attorney’s Office, Hard Knox Wire reported.

    He was accused of failing to disclose personal financial information during a conflict of interest probe, among other charges. 

     He faces a maximum prison sentence of five years plus up to three years of supervised release and $250,000 in fines when he’s sentenced in March by U.S. District Court Judge Travis R. McDonough. 

    FBI Special Agent in Charge Joe Carrico said the case was an example of the bureau’s commitment to fighting corruption. 

    “There is zero tolerance for those who exploit their official position for personal gain. It erodes public confidence and undermines the Rule of Law,” Carrico said. “We want the people we serve to know the FBI along with our law enforcement partners will hold those accountable who betray the public's trust.”

  • Clean-energy advocates take demands to base of TVA towers and power
    in Air

    IMG 4207Alex Pulsipher holds a sign demanding that TVA transition to 100 percent renewable energy at a rally Wednesday in Market Square in Knoxville. Courtesy Amy Rawe/Southern Alliance for Clean Energy

    Varied environmental groups offer unified plea for clean energy, coal ash management and accountability from TVA

    It was people power generating energy at Market Square in downtown Knoxville on Wednesday.

    A coalition of civic and environmental groups and their representatives met at the bottom of the two Tennessee Valley Authority towers urging the public utility to reopen meetings to public comment; swear off all fossil fuels by 2030; and carefully tend to the needs of those affected by coal ash and devise a plan to contain it for the safety of current and future generations.

  • 100 citizens attend ‘People’s Hearing’ on TVA and demand more accountability, transparency
    in Air

    Attendees raise concerns about coal ash; call for more clean energy, transparency and public engagement from TVA

    Nearly 100 people from Tennessee and other states served by the Tennessee Valley Authority joined a virtual People’s TVA Hearing. The hearing on Aug. 4 was organized by the Tennessee Valley Energy Democracy Movement (TVEDM). It included a public comment session and multiple breakout sessions for attendees to discuss specific issues facing TVA and the Tennessee Valley. 

    TVA has not held any public listening sessions in a year and a half because of the Covid-19 pandemic, and attendees called on TVA to resume such sessions as soon as possible when the pandemic ebbs.

    “TVA talks a good game about being public power but they are simply not walking the walk,” said Barbara Mott of Knoxville. “Hiding from the people is not the answer.”

  • FGS calls on TVA to get serious about addressing the climate crisis

    As Hellbender Press reported in April, the Tennessee Valley Authority plans to phase out its use of coal. And as we mentioned in an action alert, TVA is conducting a scoping process pertaining to the preparation of an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) for retirement and replacement of the Kingston Fossil Plant. TVA is preparing similar EIS for its other remaining coal-fired power plants as well.

    Although TVA lists "construction and operation of solar and storage facilities" in these scoping documents as an alternative for replacement of coal as the power source, it has made no secret of its belief that construction of gas-powered combustion turbines (CT) and natural gas pipelines to feed them will be the best solution to replace the outdated generation capacity.

    Unlike other power utilities, TVA has been making it more difficult, financially unattractive or impossible for distributed renewable energy, storage and even efficiency projects to get realized, according to proponents of renewables and some of TVA’s local power distribution partners. TVA also reneged on its agreement with other utilities to make large amounts of wind power available to the Southeastern United States through the Plains & Eastern Clean Line high-voltage direct-current power line project.