The Environmental Journal of Southern Appalachia
Tuesday, 06 September 2022 14:48

Public comment: Environmental group leaders say TVA makes input difficult

Written by

Handout from TVA Listening Session Aug. 30 2022Scott Banbury with the Tennessee Chapter of the Sierra Club said a handout provided at TVA’s Aug. 30 listening session stated recordings of the meeting were not allowed; a TVA spokesperson said recordings are, in fact, allowed. Flyer provided by Scott Banbury

Is TVA trying to gag its critics?

This story was originally published by Tennessee Lookout.

KNOXVILLE — While the Tennessee Valley Authority, a utility company that provides power to millions in Tennessee and other states, allows for public input into decisions, the process isn’t simple or transparent, say some regular attendees.

Take, for instance, a recent public listening session: representatives of the Tennessee Chapter of the Sierra Club say they were told they could not record the session despite a spokesman for TVA saying the opposite.

According to TVA spokesperson Scott Brooks, attendees are always allowed to record public meetings, provided they don’t cause a disturbance, but minutes before the session, members of the Tennessee chapter of the Sierra Club were prohibited from doing so.

“We pushed back on this, telling them that we already had a Facebook streaming event set up and promoted,” said Scott Banbury, Conservation Programs Coordinator for the Tennessee chapter of the Sierra Club. 

In the past, TVA allowed more public participation in their listening sessions, along with live-streaming the events. But several years ago, TVA stopped streaming the event, required speakers to register within a limited time frame and gave shorter notice as to when the listening sessions were held. And since changing their public listening sessions from being held the day of the board meeting to the day before, attendees have had increasing difficulties in publicly participating in TVA’s dealings, which are held in different locations each year.

This year, a recent session was held at the University of Tennessee at Martin, located nearly three hours away from Nashville and twice that from Knoxville, making the ability to record crucial for those wanting to stay up to date on TVA business. 

After pushing back on the recording prohibition, which was listed on set of guidelines for speakers to follow, “TVA staff conferred for a few minutes and decided it was alright to stream the event if we did so from the back of the room,” said Banbury.

“I pointed out that the Sierra Club staff (who) would be doing the streaming was in the front row next to the speakers podiums, and after conferring with each other again, TVA staff agreed to allow us to stream from the front row,” he added.

Because the session was not available online through TVA, Sierra Club members have argued that a public listening session should be made publicly available and the current format limited the ability of the public to participate in these sessions and hear concerns from other Tennessee residents. 

“It’s really the one way that a lot of people can hear from each other about what their requests are of the TVA board,” said Sierra Club member Amy Kelly, adding that TVA provides coverage to millions in six states.

This year, the Sierra Club and other speakers at the session shared their concerns about the rising cost of natural gas prices and TVA’s plans to replace a coal plant with a natural-gas plant. 

“It’s important people hear what the requests are from TVA’s board, like the 188 comments we submitted requesting TVA switch from coal to renewable energy instead of gas,” said Kelly.

In 2018, Sierra Club members sent a letter to TVA’s board of directors about the session’s limitations and asked that the TVA advertise the event, send alerts in advance,  increase time limits for speakers and overall make the sessions more convenient for the public to attend.

“As the largest grassroot environmental organization in Tennessee, we have serious concerns about the structure of the pilot,” said  Sierra Club spokesperson Jonathan Levenshus in a letter to the TVA board. 

“The late posting of the session’s details did not give people enough time to plan for attendance — even if they were able to attend a 2:30 p.m. meeting on a weekday — or address topics the board discussed during its meeting the following day. The new format also removed same-day speaker registration and the session was not streamed live so that those unable to travel or take time off from work could still be informed,” the letter read.

TVA responded that they would take their comments into consideration, but Sierra Club members have yet to see significant changes.

In 2020, TVA closed meetings to the public because of COVID-19. And because of this, the Sierra Club also held their own TVA-centered public listening sessions through the Tennessee Valley Energy Democracy Network, created to increase public participation with TVA’s coverage. 

“Now we’re back to in-person meetings but it’s this same format that doesn’t really work very well,” said Sierra Club member Bonnie Swinford. 

The most recent board meeting was the second session held in person. 

After the public listening session, TVA conducts their quarterly board meetings the following day and summarizes comments and concerns made the day before for board members to address. 

The public listening sessions are just one of many ways that the TVA offers public participation and changes were made to allow for comments to be considered before the meeting.  Pertinent information is published on their websites and social media outlets.

“The listening sessions are intended to be direct communication with the TVA board. That channel is available to anyone in writing or in person on the day before each board meeting,” said Brooks.

 

Rate this item
(1 Vote)

Related items

  • Former Tennessee Wildlife and Resources Agency biologist alleges agency manipulated data on deer disease
    in News

    fishwildlife_CWD-deer-pic_web.pngA Tennessee deer with Chronic Wasting Disease.  Tennessee Wildlife Federation

    In a lawsuit filed against the agency, the former employee claims officials misled the public about the rate of a neurological disorder in deer, changing protocols to avoid admitting mistakes.

    This story was originally published by Tennessee Lookout.

    NASHVILLE — A former state biologist claims he was confronted in his home by law enforcement officers with the Tennessee Wildlife Resources Agency on the same day he sent his boss’s superiors evidence the state was falsifying data on wildlife diseases.

    After his cell phone, laptops and other items were confiscated, the biologist said he was then subjected to hours of questioning by officers — among them the husband of his immediate supervisor.  

    James Kelly (video link features Kelly at 10 minutes), a wildlife biologist, led the Tennessee Wildlife Resources Agency’s deer management program, chaired the agency’s Chronic Wasting Disease (CWD) Deer Management Standing Team and served as a wildlife biologist until he was fired in 2022.

    In a whistleblower lawsuit filed this week, Kelly alleges state officials manipulated data and misled the public about the prevalence of chronic wasting disease, a fatal and infectious disease that attacks deer populations.

    (TWRA would not comment on the specific allegations in the filing, but said its data was solid).

  • To critics’ dismay, TVA plans to replace coal with natural gas. The utility also plans to double its solar supply.
    in News

    image001.jpg

    Citizens call on TVA to stop passing gas

    KNOXVILLE — The Tennessee Valley Authority in coming years plans to add both natural gas and solar plants to its portfolio to meet what it says are rising energy demands.

    TVA’s Board of Directors laid out the federal utility’s plan in a meeting at Norris Middle School in May. Environmentalists at a previous hearing criticized the utility’s focus on natural gas rather than renewables or other measures. Other people, largely tied to local power providers, argued that a switch to renewable energy would be unreliable.

    TVA showed a map in a press release following the meeting, showing four proposed natural gas plants and two proposed solar plants. Two of those natural gas plants would be in Tennessee while the other two are planned for Alabama and Kentucky. It stated these new plants will total 3,800 megawatts. It also spoke of its System Operations Center, set to open in fall 2024 in Georgetown to manage the utility’s grid. TVA also stated a desire to research nuclear technologies.

    “Our region is experiencing growth at six times the national average, which means we must invest in our current power system and build new generation so we can continue meeting our region’s demand,” said TVA president and CEO Jeff Lyash.

    Several citizens criticized TVA’s focus on natural gas plants and new pipelines at the listening session May 9. Among them was Clinton resident and activist John Todd Waterman.

  • Water and waste on TVA agenda as utility plans Bull Run shutdown
    in News

    TVA’s Bull Run Fossil Plant — then and nowBull Run Fossil Plant in Claxton, Tennessee, was originally commissioned 55 years ago but TVA is now soliciting public input on the best way to shut down operations. Tennessee Valley Authority

    TVA solicits public input following release of environmental assessment for Bull Run Fossil Plant decommission

    CLAXTON — Tennessee Valley Authority plans to close its Bull Run Fossil Plant (BRF) in Anderson County, but it’s still looking for public input on what comes next.

    “As a large, inflexible coal unit with medium operating costs and a high forced outage rate, BRF does not fit current and likely future portfolio needs,” the federal utility said in a draft Environmental Assessment.

    TVA is looking at three different options for the future of the structures still standing on the site by the Clinch River near Oak Ridge: taking down all structures; taking down some of them; or leaving everything standing. A recent report lays out the environmental consequences of each of these actions. The report, in draft form, is against that third choice, listing it as only an option for the sake of comparison.

    “If the facility is left in the “as-is” condition, it likely would present a higher risk than Alternatives A or B for the potential to contaminate soil and groundwater as systems and structures degrade. As such, this alternative is not a reasonable alternative,” the draft states.

    TVA stated its considering removing “all or most of the buildings and structures” on a 250-acre area. After closing the plant, but before any demolitions, TVA will begin by removing components that may be used at other TVA sites, draining of oil and fluids from equipment, taking ash out of the boilers, removing information technology assets, removing plant records and other tasks.

    The Bull Run Environmental Assessment is 170 pages long and available for public review. It doesn’t directly tackle the coal ash storage conundrum that has grabbed the attention of politicians, nearby residents and environmental activists, because that issue involves separate regulations. 

  • Seeing the city for the trees
    in News

    IMG 2632This mighty oak is but one of many growing for decades in South Knoxville.  Thomas Fraser/Hellbender Press

    Contribute to the master plan to grow tree canopy in Knoxville

    KNOXVILLE — No matter where you are in the city, you’re not far from a patch or two of trees.

    These copses range from small groupings of oaks or dogwoods that are commonly used to mark property boundaries to lush belts of temperate mixed-hardwood forest that sprawl across hundreds of acres. 

    While Knoxville may be blessed with an abundance of these urban forests, many local residents and leaders believe it’s nowhere near enough.

  • ‘I remember the marks in his ankle:’ Paddlers push for trotline regulations on Tennessee waterways
    in News

    Silver anchor and thin fishing line tied to a branch for an underwater trotlineSilver weight and thin fishing line tied to a branch for an underwater trotline.  Getty Images via Tennessee Lookout

    Traditional Tennessee trot lines pose a fatal collision with river recreation

    This story was originally published by Tennessee Lookout.

    NASHVILLE Brandon Archer was canoeing down the Buffalo River with friends over Labor Day weekend three years ago when he jumped out for a swim and drowned.

    Archer had become entangled in a trotline, an unmanned fishing line studded with hooks that stretched across the river. The MTSU football player died a day shy of his 22nd birthday.

    “When they found him he was under 10 feet of water and they found trotline wrapped around his ankle,” Courtney Archer, Brandon’s mother, told members of the Tennessee Fish and Wildlife Commission this month. “When I saw my son I remember the marks in his ankle from the trotline that was there.”

  • Every TVA coal-fired plant in Tennessee is leaking dangerous contaminants at unsafe levels, report concludes
    in News

    TVA‘s Cumberland power plantThe Tennessee Valley Authority’s Cumberland Fossil Plant in Stewart County, Tennessee is leaking boron at 22 times safe levels, as well as unsafe levels of arsenic, cobalt, lithium and molybdenum, according to a recent report prepared by environmental groups using TVA’s own data. Tennessee Valley Authority

    Report: TVA’s Allen Fossil Plant in Memphis ranks No. 10 in most contaminated U.S. sites

    This story was originally published by Tennessee Lookout.

    The Tennessee Valley Authority’s coal ash dumps in Memphis rank among the worst in the nation for contamination of groundwater with cancer-causing toxins, according to a new report that relied on the power provider’s own records.

    TVA’s coal ash dumps at the now-defunct Allen Fossil Plant rank as the 10th worst contaminated sites in the country in a report released earlier this month that examined groundwater monitoring data from coal-fired plant operators, including TVA.

    TVA’s own monitoring data shows its Memphis dumps are leaking arsenic at levels nearly 300 times safe drinking water limits. Unsafe levels of boron, lead and molybdenum are also being recorded there.

    The report, prepared and published by the Environmental Integrity Project (EIP) and Earthjustice, shows that coal ash dumps at every TVA coal-fired facility across Tennessee are leaking dangerous contaminants at unsafe levels, including arsenic, cobalt, lithium, molybedenum, boron, lead and sulfate, into groundwater.

  • Still no reckoning for coal-ash polluters
    in News

    1024px Kingston plant spill swanpond tn2A TVA ash pond at Watts Bar ruptured with disastrous consequences in December 2008.  Wikipedia 

    Report contends coal plant operators are shirking responsibilities on ash cleanup

    This story was originally published by Tennessee Lookout

    NASHVILLE — In the wake of major coal ash spills from power plant containment ponds in Tennessee and into the Dan River along the North Carolina and Virginia border, the federal Environmental Protection Agency in 2015 laid out the first federal rules for managing the ash, one of the nation’s largest waste streams, and the toxins it contains.  

    But more than seven years later, few utilities and other owners responsible for the often unlined pits where billions of tons of ash leach heavy metals and other toxins into groundwater are planning comprehensive cleanups, per a report released this month by a pair of environmental groups. 

  • Help control invasive exotic plants Saturday at Oak Ridge cedar barrens

    Oak Ridge Cedar Barrens fall 2022

     

    OAK RIDGE — The Oak Ridge Cedar Barren will again be the site of exotic invasive plant removal on Saturday, Nov. 5 as we conduct our fall cleanup, our third and final cleanup of the year.  Located next to Jefferson Middle School in Oak Ridge, the Barren is a joint project of the City of Oak Ridge, State Natural Areas Division, and Tennessee Citizens for Wilderness Planning. The area is one of just a few cedar barrens in East Tennessee, and is subject to invasion by bushy lespedeza, leatherleaf viburnum, privet, autumn olive, mimosa, Nepal grass, multiflora rose, and woody plants that threaten the system’s prairie grasses. Our efforts help to eliminate invasives and other shade-producing plants that prevent the prairie grasses from getting needed sunlight.

    Volunteers should meet in the Jefferson Middle School Parking lot at 9 a.m., with sturdy shoes, loppers, gloves, and water.  The work session will conclude at noon with a pizza lunch. For more information, contact Tim Bigelow at 865-607-6781 or This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..

    Hellbender Press reported in detail on last year’s Cedar Barren spring cleanup.

  • Advance Knox envisions three trajectories for development in Knox County, wants your opinion by Oct. 31
    in News

    Advance Knox Choices WeekAdvance Knox proposes three growth scenarios for the future of the unincorporated areas of Knox County.

    If you missed the community meetings and the Zoom event during Advance Knox’s “Choices Week,” you can still take the survey online!

    If you are unfamiliar with the Advance Knox project, you may find it helpful to watch the first 19 minutes of the Choices Week webinar recording before taking the survey.

    Advance Knox is a process to prepare a land use and transportation plan for Knox County that is informed by research and community input,” according to its website.

    In March 2022, Advance Knox offered a first round of public input opportunities during its “Ideas Week.”  As reported in Hellbender Press, community meetings were held all over the county. Participation opportunities at special group presentations, a Zoom webinar, and individual commenting on the website were similar to those of Choices Week.

  • Activists urge TVA to take advantage of historic US climate bill for energy-efficiency improvements
    in News

    TVA 1 2048x1365A hopper car on a train filled with coal to be delivered to a TVA coal-fired plant. John Partipilo/Tennessee Lookout

    Climate bill designates TVA as a potential recipient of clean energy investments and loans

    This story was originally published by Tennessee Lookout.

    KNOXVILLE  Clean-energy advocates are urging the Tennessee Valley Authority to use funds provided through the Inflation Reduction Act to deliver environmentally friendly energy to Tennessee customers. 

    The massive bill Congress passed Friday includes $370 billion for clean energy investments and listed TVA as an entity that is eligible to take advantage of clean energy credits and loans to significantly reduce the cost of energy-efficient infrastructure. 

    On Aug. 12, the Clean Up TVA Coalition, including the Sierra Club, the Southern Alliance for Clean Energy and Appalachian Voices, urged TVA to take advantage of the legislation and make funds available to its affiliated local power companies, which can then offer energy-efficient options for customers.