The Environmental Journal of Southern Appalachia
Sunday, 31 July 2022 11:37

Has the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians lost its ‘right way’ at Exit 407?

Written by

Will West LongCherokee tribal council member, historian and ethnographer Will West Long holds a traditional Cherokee mask, which he often recreated. He was an active chronicler of Cherokee custom, heritage and tradition and died in 1947 on the Qualla Reservation in Swain County, North Carolina. WikiCommons

As plans gel for massive new developments, has the Eastern Band lost its ancient way?

SEVIERVILLE — The Tennessee Department of Transportation is eyeing a second interchange for exit 407 at Highway 66 along Interstate I-40 in Sevier County. 

Exit 407, already one of the most congested interchanges in Southern Appalachia, accesses the main highway to Great Smoky Mountains National Park, the most visited national park in the nation. The park reported a record 14 million visitors in 2021.

The exit also serves crowds flocking to Pigeon Forge and Gatlinburg.

But the new interchange would primarily serve a 200-acre development to be called Exit 407: The Gateway to Adventure.   

Scheduled to open spring 2023, and fully operational in 2024, it’s expected to attract 6.7 million people annually. The first phase includes a theme park and a 74,000-square-foot convenience store with 120 gas pumps, making it the world’s largest such store.

It would be France-based theme-park company Puy du Fue’s first venture into North America. Texas-based convenience-store chain Buc-ee’s, known for its Texas-sized stores, is also the first named feature of a multi-phase planned tourist destination. 

Visitors will now have even more commercial attractions to visit before entering one of the most ecologically diverse intact wildernesses left on Earth: Great Smoky Mountains National Park.

The new theme park will be a twist on the classic theme park. It’s being billed as a spectacular, immersive experience stressing production value over rides and normal forms of entertainment. The park’s theme will center on the important role the Cherokee Nation played in WWI.

Boasting exceptionally clean, over-sized bathrooms, Buc-ee’s is a tourist destination unto itself. It even enjoys a cult following.

When asked where they’re going on vacation, fans say Buc-ee’s first, then their ultimate destination, planning their route expressly to stop at locations along the interstates, where they can use their Buc-ee’s credit card. When they arrive, in case they forget what country they’re in, there are big American flags everywhere.

Their young’uns can be introduced to Western excess and ultimate convenience by becoming Buckaroos. They even get their own child-sized shopping cart to push around, adorned with a colorful pole and flag, so parents can find their wandering herd grazing on the over-packaged, over-lit, single-use plastic prairie aisles.  

And before leaving the parking lot, customers will be able to ride through the world’s longest car wash, with a 255-foot conveyor.

Buc-ee’s never closes, and never dims their overly-bright lights, both inside and out, meant to be seen from the interstate long before arriving.  

You’d certainly think it’s a wonderful thing to have the world’s largest convenience store coming to East Tennessee, the way expectant future customers gush with pride and excitement in the local media.

The 407: Gateway to Adventure is being built on land owned and managed by the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians — Kituwah LLC.

The Eastern Band did not respond to requests for comment.

The Right Way 

The Cherokee Nation has been, in the past, the standard bearer of sustainable living in southern Appalachia. This ethos they called Duyuk’ dv’ I: The Right Way. They took only what was needed from the land to live.

To instill this right way of living, children were taught that over-hunting causes animals to retaliate with diseases for upsetting the natural balance. The only way to set things right was to apologize to the wildlife, then limit hunts.     

They were a people with an ancient connection to nature. They mingled with the spirits of plants, animals, landforms and waters, with a harmonious reverence of their place in the world.  

They also governed with this same ethos. The thriving chains of towns along the river valleys of Southern Appalachia were organized as a confederacy, independent communities united by a common, 11,000-year-old continuous culture pre-dating the Mayans. There is even evidence the Cherokees hunted mastodons in Southern Appalachia.

They were so attuned and interconnected to their natural environment they called the waters beginning in the mountains of Virginia and North Carolina flowing south toward Chattanooga as Yunwi Gunahita, The Long Man.

What Ganvhidv Asgaya means to us. (1-minute video)

They practiced organic and sustainable permaculture, interplanting corn, beans and squash. Because of the way the plants worked together, providing ecological services to each other, they called them The Three Sisters.

Abundant rainfall, and the transpiring tree canopies above the fern-carpeted forest floor, created the iconic misty conditions associated with the Smokies. Water vapor carried mostly non-volatile organic compounds and fragrant pollen; unlike the human-created gray haze we see today.

Then the Europeans came

The Europeans arrived with their White, Anglo-Saxon view of wilderness prevalent at the time: It must be beaten back and used up.

Instead of a biologically diverse land of countless ridges dividing the dark cathedral forest, with its lingering mist, they saw a gold mine for the taking.

The Europeans made fun of the Cherokees. Instead of large, roaring fires requiring stacks of firewood, the Indians built small, controlled fires, having little impact on the land. This kind of fire the Europeans derisively named “Indian fires”.     

Things began to change in the river valleys of Southern Appalachia. Even on perfectly clear days without the ubiquitous mist, distant mountains, once clearly visible, began to slowly disappear on the horizon, and the air seemed to have an unnatural color.

New plant and animal species were invading and wreaking havoc on the local, established ecosystem.   

For the most part, the Cherokee lived peacefully with their new neighbors. They began trading animal skins for guns, and iron useful for farming. This led to longer and larger hunts, doubling the pressure the Europeans alone put on wildlife.  

As useful as guns and iron were, overall, as a nation, the Cherokees bemoaned modern encroachment and the extractive mindset. 

In 1838, the U.S. government evicted the Cherokee from their native lands. This forced, overland removal to Oklahoma became known as the Trail of Tears, parts of which can be traced today.

Some Cherokees remained, refusing to abide by the government order. Those that hid in the mountains eventually became one of the few tribes to return to normal life in their ancestral lands.

The Cherokee originally called their home Land of the Blue Mist, which the Europeans translated to The Smoky Mountains, or just The Smokies. As the region started to become popular with leisure travelers, the locals, for marketing purposes, began calling this part of Southern Appalachia The Great Smoky Mountains.

Classic bait and switch

The town of Cherokee, North Carolina became the place the Eastern Band of the Cherokee Nation chose to showcase themselves to this new world.

Visitors once headed to the quieter side of the Smokies in North Carolina, where they were introduced to the old Cherokee way of life. Now they’ll be funneled to The 407: Gateway to Adventure.

So much for Duyuk’ dv’ I.

Far from Exit 407, the town of Cherokee is a place far removed from modern life. A place where researchers and historians, nature lovers and creative artisans, using natural materials, immersed themself in an environment harkening back to a time when humans coexisted with nature, in a sustainable, harmonious balance. It’s a place to explore firsthand the benefits of interconnectedness, when nature is not the Other.

The whole town is a living tribute to this heritage, and the Cherokee Nation sold us on this legacy for years.

Now we get the world’s largest convenience store.

They used to live sustainably off the land, now they use this land to fuel their growing economy.

The Eastern Band of Cherokees have replaced their centuries-old ethos to become a major player in further developing Sevier County, which includes a large portion of Great Smoky Mountains National Park.

It does make sense, though, to use all the commercial means available to right the wrongs the United States committed against them, extracting money from the same people whose forefathers tried to wipe them out.     

The cost of convenience    

Buying in bulk, as opposed to single-use containers, is nature friendly. Extreme over-packaging of convenience items is exactly the opposite.

Not only are convenience items more expensive, they also carry a higher cost to the environment  

Is a convenience store the size of some WalMarts still a convenience store? And if so, convenient to who? Certainly not the people who are actually going to the mountains to commune with nature, but instead must first navigate the extra traffic brought by The 407: Gateway to Adventure development.

The former hunter-gatherers of the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians will now be able to get their meat from Buc-ee’s beef-jerky bar, which offers every kind of beef jerky imaginable, except mastodon.

Much has changed since the Cherokee first stepped foot in the mountains of Southern Appalachia. So has our relationship with nature.

Rate this item
(3 votes)
Published in News, Voices

Related items

  • Appalachian trout in trouble as temps rise, storms rage
    in News

    trout_bradley.jpg.webpMichael Bradley, a fly-fishing guide, on Raven Fork in the Oconaluftee area of the Great Smoky Mountains.  U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

    Climate change could steal your fish

    Dan Chapman is a public affairs specialist for the Southeast Region of U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.

    CHEROKEE — The mountains of the Southern Appalachians were scraped clean a century ago. Headwater ecology changed as the canopy of trees disappeared that was shading the streams from all but the noonday sun. Rainstorms pushed dirt and rocks into the water muddying the feeding and breeding grounds of fish, amphibians and insects. 

    Lower down the mountain, newly cut pastures edged right up to the creeks while cows mucked up the once-pristine waters. Invasive bugs killed hemlocks, ash and other shade-giving trees. Pipes, culverts and dams blockaded streams and kept animals from cooler water. 

    The trout never had a chance.

    Now they face an even more insidious foe — climate change. 

  • Here’s an updated summer primer for the end of the world as we know it
    in News

    halloween sun 2014 2kThe Earth’s sun is seen in this NASA image. Scientists said July might be the hottest month in 100,000 years.  

    The global heat wave of July 2023 has spared Southern Appalachia. So far.

    KNOXVILLE July 2023 has so far offered a scary look at global climate change around the world, and the month is already one for the record books.

    This month will likely end up being the hottest July on record, globally speaking. That comes after quantitative conclusions from multiple scientists that the past week was, globally, the warmest in 100,000 years.

    The Southern Appalachians have generally been spared from the heat settling on vast portions of the country and world, but that will soon change. The National Weather Service predicts higher than average temperatures flirting with 100 degrees in the Tennessee Valley next week. Record-breaking temperatures are possible. The average high temperature for July in Knoxville is 87 degrees.

  • The Mingus music mill: Tracing a mountain family’s history from slavery to stardom
    in News

    Charles Mingus Jr. 1976, cropped Charles Mingus, the descendant of slaves from the Smokies, is shown chomping a cigar and playing bass at the U.S. Bicentennial celebration in Lower Manhattan, July 4, 1976. Creative Commons Mark Tom Marcello 

    Smokies African American studies trace a great musician with roots in Oconaluftee 

    GATLINBURG ­— Black history, let alone jazz history, isn’t the first thing that comes to mind when most people think about the Smokies.

    But famed jazz musician Charles Mingus Jr.’s family has roots in what is now Great Smoky Mountains National Park.

    At the recent virtual Discover Life in America Colloquium, previously reported on by Hellbender Press, Appalachian Highlands Science Education Coordinator Antoine Fletcher was the sole presenter on social sciences. He went into the Mingus family history and Black history in the Southern Appalachian region.

    Fletcher said the Mingus story derives from the African American Experiences in the Smokies Project, which he described as “a project that is focusing on the untold stories of African Americans in the park and the Southern Appalachian region.”

    “There’s a huge story to tell,” he said of his research. “There are stories of the human vestiges that we have from 900-plus years.”

  • From soil to sky: Will the misty microclimates of the Smokies prevail in a warming world?
    in News

    IMG 7863With the help of GPS coordinates and survey flags, Jordan Stark is able to deploy and locate the exact off-trail placement of soil moisture sensors she placed in Great Smoky Mountains National Park as part of her graduate research at Syracuse University.  Elan Young/Hellbender Press

    Foundational ecology moves from before times to nowadays in the Smokies

    GATLINBURG — In the Middle Ages, salamanders were thought to come from fire. A log set on the hearth would send them scurrying out of the rotten wood, startling those who had gathered around for warmth. We now know that salamanders, of course, come from water — even the European fire salamander with its flame-like yellow markings.

    Over the last 20 years of getting my boots soggy in Great Smoky Mountains National Park, I know these creatures to thrive in the clean, shallow streams and trickles of this temperate rainforest, where annual precipitation is higher than anywhere in the U.S. save for the Pacific Northwest.

    One way to become acquainted with the park is through the water that veins through the hills and is transmuted into vapor that floats on the air in misty silence. After a rain, you can slake your thirst from the pools formed in the creases of broad rhododendron leaves. Sit by a shallow, fishless stream for long enough and you might spot the quick movement of a salamander tail, maybe a flash of orange or brown, or notice a tiny black amphibian face peeking out from behind a smooth stone in the creek.

  • 2016 Smokies wildfires: Six years later, the good and the bad come into focus as natural recovery continues
    in News

    COVER 1208 GatlinburgsInferno1Journalists and park officials document damage from the November 2016 wildfires that killed at least 15 people and left hundreds of dwellings and businesses in ruins. Thomas Fraser/Hellbender Press via Knoxville Mercury

    How the 2016 Great Smoky Mountains National Park wildfire affected salamanders and other life, six years on

    GATLINBURG  The disastrous Chimney Tops 2 wildfire of 2016 occurred some six years ago, but researchers are still looking at its ecological effects.

    The Discover Life in America 2023 Colloquium brought together researchers this month from different fields and universities to present findings on research in Great Smoky Mountains National Park. 

    Researchers presented on many topics, ranging from trout to the history of the Mingus family in the park.

    One such presentation, the first of the day, from William Peterman, associate professor in wildlife ecology and management at Ohio State University, focused on the effects wildfires had on salamander populations, which he described as negative.

    Other presenters touched on the wildfire’s effects as well, including its effects on vegetation and its beneficial effects on the diversity of bird species.

    “Smoky Mountains is the self-proclaimed salamander capital of the world,” Peterman said. He focused his study on the plethodontid family of salamanders, which breathe through their skin.

    “Kind of think of them as a walking lung,” he said.

  • Updated 1/3: Conservationists express dismay as Feds conclude ‘no significant impact’ from construction of Wears Valley mountain bike complex
    in News

    Foothills parkway

    Feds clear 14-mile mountain bike trail network off Foothills Parkway, but no funding is secured 

    GATLINBURG — Those who logged protests against a National Park Service plan to carve a 14-mile mountain bike trail network through the forest off Foothills Parkway said they still opposed the plan despite federal conclusions it would not adversely impact the natural environment of the area. 

    “I’m very disappointed,” said Donna Edwards, an outspoken conservationist who lives in Walland and participated in the public scoping process. “What are (the) reasons for choosing the alternative with the largest footprint and greatest environmental impact?

    “I fail to understand why mountain bikers’ needs are considered to be more important than those of birders and hikers, considering the extensive mountain bike trail networks in other areas of East Tennessee.”

    She said arguments against approving the Wears Valley mountain bike trails were wise and well documented.

    Here is the original Hellbender Press story:

    A proposed off-road bike trail in the Wears Valley section of the Foothills Parkway that would be operated by the National Park Service has overcome a procedural hurdle but appears to be no closer to actually being built due to a lack of funding. 

    An environmental assessment to determine the project’s potential impact on wildlife and the environment led to an official “Finding of No Significant Impact” (FONSI), park officials said in a press release issued Thursday. 

    “We understand the public’s desire to have a purpose-built bike trail, and this marks a step for potential future development of a trail in Wears Valley,” said Cassius Cash, superintendent of the Great Smoky Mountains National Park. “Having the signed FONSI allows us the opportunity to explore potential funding paths for both the construction and the annual operational costs.”

  • Updated: Smokies crews recover drowned Knoxville kayaker

    TOWNSEND — Smokies recovery teams on Monday found the body of Carl Keaney, 61, of Knoxville, in the Little River.

    Keaney was last seen kayaking the Sinks during high flow when he vanished under water, prompting calls to Great Smoky Mountains National Park rangers who, along with other local crews, proceeded to search for his body for three days.

    Here’s the previous Hellbender Press report:

    Teams are searching for a missing kayaker in what Great Smoky Mountains National Park officials are now calling a “recovery operation” after a 61-year-old man disappeared underwater while boating above the Sinks on Little River. High water levels from recent heavy rains are making search and recovery difficult.

    “Around 3:40 p.m. on Friday, Dec. 16 Great Smoky Mountains National Park dispatch received a call that a 61-year-old man had disappeared underwater while kayaking above The Sinks and did not resurface,” according to a news release from the park. 

  • For the win: The storied snail darter swims back from the brink
    in News

    Snail DarterThe snail darter, which caused an epic battle around TVA plans to dam the Tellico River in the 1970s, was recently removed from the Endangered Species List. Jeremy Monroe/Tennessee Aquarium

    The little fish that caused a maelstrom over a TVA dam project gets the last laugh

    TELLICO — In a win for endangered species protected by federal law, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service announced this week the fabled snail darter’s recovery and removal from the Federal List of Threatened and Endangered Wildlife. 

    Native to the Tennessee River watershed in Alabama, Georgia, Mississippi and Tennessee, the fish has long been an Endangered Species Act icon thanks to conservation efforts to save its habitat starting in the 1970s, when the Tennessee Valley Authority proposed construction of a dam on the Little Tennessee River. The snail darter (Percina tanasi) was central in the 1978 U.S. Supreme Court case Tennessee Valley Authority v. Hill, which solidified the scope of the then recently passed ESA. 

  • Celebrate the wild ties that bind Americans on Public Lands Day 2022 — Saturday, Sept. 24


    GATLINBURG — The director of the National Park Service is expected in Great Smoky Mountains National Park on Saturday to celebrate National Public Lands Day.

    Director Chuck Sams plans to make some remarks in appreciation for the volunteers who help backstop national park maintenance costs before citizens fan out for various tasks across the park. Sams is the first Native American to head the park service, and he will be joined by Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians Chief Richard G. Sneed.

  • Parking fees set for Smokies; camping costs will increase
    in News

    IMG 6088You might have to pay to park at some of these trailheads in Great Smoky Mountains National Park starting next year. These old trail badges are displayed in Fontana Village on the south side of the Smokies. Thomas Fraser/Hellbender Press

    Smokies parking fees will generate $7 million in revenue for park infrastructure

    GATLINBURG — Getting outside just got more expensive.

    Great Smoky Mountains National Park officials announced Monday the park would proceed with plans for a $5/per day parking pass required of all cars staying in one spot for more than 15 minutes.

    Weekly passes will be $15, and annual passes will be available for $40, according to a release from the park service. Fees will also increase $3 for backcountry and campground permits, meaning campers and backpackers will have to fork over $8 a night.