The Environmental Journal of Southern Appalachia

Has the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians lost its ‘right way’ at Exit 407?

Written by

Will West LongCherokee tribal council member, historian and ethnographer Will West Long holds a traditional Cherokee mask, which he often recreated. He was an active chronicler of Cherokee custom, heritage and tradition and died in 1947 on the Qualla Reservation in Swain County, North Carolina. WikiCommons

As plans gel for massive new developments, has the Eastern Band lost its ancient way?

SEVIERVILLE The Tennessee Department of Transportation is eyeing a second interchange for exit 407 at Highway 66 along Interstate I-40 in Sevier County. 

Exit 407, already one of the most congested interchanges in Southern Appalachia, accesses the main highway to Great Smoky Mountains National Park, the most visited national park in the nation. The park reported a record 14 million visitors in 2021.

The exit also serves crowds flocking to Pigeon Forge and Gatlinburg.

But the new interchange would primarily serve a 200-acre development to be called Exit 407: The Gateway to Adventure.   

Scheduled to open spring 2023, and fully operational in 2024, it’s expected to attract 6.7 million people annually. The first phase includes a theme park and a 74,000-square-foot convenience store with 120 gas pumps, making it the world’s largest such store.

It would be France-based theme-park company Puy du Fue’s first venture into North America. Texas-based convenience-store chain Buc-ee’s, known for its Texas-sized stores, is also the first named feature of a multi-phase planned tourist destination. 

Visitors will now have even more commercial attractions to visit before entering one of the most ecologically diverse intact wildernesses left on Earth: Great Smoky Mountains National Park.

The new theme park will be a twist on the classic theme park. It’s being billed as a spectacular, immersive experience stressing production value over rides and normal forms of entertainment. The park’s theme will center on the important role the Cherokee Nation played in WWI.

Boasting exceptionally clean, over-sized bathrooms, Buc-ee’s is a tourist destination unto itself. It even enjoys a cult following.

When asked where they’re going on vacation, fans say Buc-ee’s first, then their ultimate destination, planning their route expressly to stop at locations along the interstates, where they can use their Buc-ee’s credit card. When they arrive, in case they forget what country they’re in, there are big American flags everywhere.

Their young’uns can be introduced to Western excess and ultimate convenience by becoming Buckaroos. They even get their own child-sized shopping cart to push around, adorned with a colorful pole and flag, so parents can find their wandering herd grazing on the over-packaged, over-lit, single-use plastic prairie aisles.  

And before leaving the parking lot, customers will be able to ride through the world’s longest car wash, with a 255-foot conveyor.

Buc-ee’s never closes, and never dims their overly-bright lights, both inside and out, meant to be seen from the interstate long before arriving.  

You’d certainly think it’s a wonderful thing to have the world’s largest convenience store coming to East Tennessee, the way expectant future customers gush with pride and excitement in the local media.

The 407: Gateway to Adventure is being built on land owned and managed by the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians — Kituwah LLC.

The Eastern Band did not respond to requests for comment.

The Right Way 

The Cherokee Nation has been, in the past, the standard bearer of sustainable living in southern Appalachia. This ethos they called Duyuk’ dv’ I: The Right Way. They took only what was needed from the land to live.

To instill this right way of living, children were taught that over-hunting causes animals to retaliate with diseases for upsetting the natural balance. The only way to set things right was to apologize to the wildlife, then limit hunts.     

They were a people with an ancient connection to nature. They mingled with the spirits of plants, animals, landforms and waters, with a harmonious reverence of their place in the world.  

They also governed with this same ethos. The thriving chains of towns along the river valleys of Southern Appalachia were organized as a confederacy, independent communities united by a common, 11,000-year-old continuous culture pre-dating the Mayans. There is even evidence the Cherokees hunted mastodons in Southern Appalachia.

They were so attuned and interconnected to their natural environment they called the waters beginning in the mountains of Virginia and North Carolina flowing south toward Chattanooga as Yunwi Gunahita, The Long Man.

What Ganvhidv Asgaya means to us. (1-minute video)

They practiced organic and sustainable permaculture, interplanting corn, beans and squash. Because of the way the plants worked together, providing ecological services to each other, they called them The Three Sisters.

Abundant rainfall, and the transpiring tree canopies above the fern-carpeted forest floor, created the iconic misty conditions associated with the Smokies. Water vapor carried mostly non-volatile organic compounds and fragrant pollen; unlike the human-created gray haze we see today.

Then the Europeans came

The Europeans arrived with their White, Anglo-Saxon view of wilderness prevalent at the time: It must be beaten back and used up.

Instead of a biologically diverse land of countless ridges dividing the dark cathedral forest, with its lingering mist, they saw a gold mine for the taking.

The Europeans made fun of the Cherokees. Instead of large, roaring fires requiring stacks of firewood, the Indians built small, controlled fires, having little impact on the land. This kind of fire the Europeans derisively named “Indian fires”.     

Things began to change in the river valleys of Southern Appalachia. Even on perfectly clear days without the ubiquitous mist, distant mountains, once clearly visible, began to slowly disappear on the horizon, and the air seemed to have an unnatural color.

New plant and animal species were invading and wreaking havoc on the local, established ecosystem.   

For the most part, the Cherokee lived peacefully with their new neighbors. They began trading animal skins for guns, and iron useful for farming. This led to longer and larger hunts, doubling the pressure the Europeans alone put on wildlife.  

As useful as guns and iron were, overall, as a nation, the Cherokees bemoaned modern encroachment and the extractive mindset. 

In 1838, the U.S. government evicted the Cherokee from their native lands. This forced, overland removal to Oklahoma became known as the Trail of Tears, parts of which can be traced today.

Some Cherokees remained, refusing to abide by the government order. Those that hid in the mountains eventually became one of the few tribes to return to normal life in their ancestral lands.

The Cherokee originally called their home Land of the Blue Mist, which the Europeans translated to The Smoky Mountains, or just The Smokies. As the region started to become popular with leisure travelers, the locals, for marketing purposes, began calling this part of Southern Appalachia The Great Smoky Mountains.

Classic bait and switch

The town of Cherokee, North Carolina became the place the Eastern Band of the Cherokee Nation chose to showcase themselves to this new world.

Visitors once headed to the quieter side of the Smokies in North Carolina, where they were introduced to the old Cherokee way of life. Now they’ll be funneled to The 407: Gateway to Adventure.

So much for Duyuk’ dv’ I.

Far from Exit 407, the town of Cherokee is a place far removed from modern life. A place where researchers and historians, nature lovers and creative artisans, using natural materials, immersed themself in an environment harkening back to a time when humans coexisted with nature, in a sustainable, harmonious balance. It’s a place to explore firsthand the benefits of interconnectedness, when nature is not the Other.

The whole town is a living tribute to this heritage, and the Cherokee Nation sold us on this legacy for years.

Now we get the world’s largest convenience store.

They used to live sustainably off the land, now they use this land to fuel their growing economy.

The Eastern Band of Cherokees have replaced their centuries-old ethos to become a major player in further developing Sevier County, which includes a large portion of Great Smoky Mountains National Park.

It does make sense, though, to use all the commercial means available to right the wrongs the United States committed against them, extracting money from the same people whose forefathers tried to wipe them out.     

The cost of convenience    

Buying in bulk, as opposed to single-use containers, is nature friendly. Extreme over-packaging of convenience items is exactly the opposite.

Not only are convenience items more expensive, they also carry a higher cost to the environment  

Is a convenience store the size of some WalMarts still a convenience store? And if so, convenient to who? Certainly not the people who are actually going to the mountains to commune with nature, but instead must first navigate the extra traffic brought by The 407: Gateway to Adventure development.

The former hunter-gatherers of the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians will now be able to get their meat from Buc-ee’s beef-jerky bar, which offers every kind of beef jerky imaginable, except mastodon.

Much has changed since the Cherokee first stepped foot in the mountains of Southern Appalachia. So has our relationship with nature.

Rate this item
(1 Vote)
Published in News, Voices

Related items

  • Falling trees accountable for very few deaths in Smokies, but they do happen

    CITIZEN TIMES: Child killed by falling tree was a very rare twist of horrible fate

    Karen Chavez of the Asheville Citizen Times wrote a great article on tree-related deaths in Great Smoky Mountains National Park and beyond following the death last week of a Georgia child killed by a falling tree as she was occupying a tent in Elkmont Campground.

    She reports the death of the child was only the 11th tree-linked death in the national park's history.

    The first such death was reported in 1934, when a Civil Conservation Corps worker was killed. Tree-related deaths since are normally associated with roadways and hiking trails.

    “‘Deaths related to falling trees or limbs account for about 2 percent of total recorded deaths in the park. It's an incredibly rare and tragic occurrence and accounts for the first-ever fatality caused by a tree falling on a tent in park history,’” according to an interview Chavez had with park spokeswoman Dana Soehn.

  • Updated: Summer of weather anomalies continues as deadly floods ravage SE Kentucky
    in News

    ky floodsHeavy flooding is seen in eastern Kentucky this weekend. State of Kentucky/Office of Gov. Andy Beshear

    Another round of severe flooding hits the Southern Appalachian region

    UPDATED: The death toll from last week’s unprecedented flooding in Kentucky reached at least 29, as some areas contended with additional flooding over the weekend. Fifteen of those, including four children, died in Knott County, which is about 100 miles north of Kingsport.

    Water service to nearly 67,000 connections has been affected, as well as 17 wastewater-treatment systems in eastern Kentucky, according to Gov. Andy Beshear’s office. 

    “We are currently experiencing one of the worst, most devastating flooding events in Kentucky’s history. The situation is dynamic and ongoing,” Beshear said in a statement.

    “What we are going to see coming out of this is massive property damage and we expect loss of life. Hundreds will lose their homes. And this will be yet another event that will take not months, but years, for our families to rebuild and recover from.”

  • Falling tree kills child in Great Smokies

    ELKMONT A 9-year-old girl died early Wednesday after a tree fell on a tent she was occupying in Great Smoky Mountains National Park.

    The unidentified child was among a group of people camping in Elkmont Campground when the red maple, 2 feet in diameter, fell shortly after midnight and crushed the girl in her tent, according to the National Park Service.

    The girl and her family had traveled to the national park from Georgia. Her father and two siblings weren’t injured, according to the park service.

    Elkmont Campground remains open, but the family’s campsite and an adjacent campsite were temporarily closed.

  • Torrential rains in Smokies destroy trails, roads and other infrastructure
    in News

    7.13.22 Porters Creek Road washoutA washout is seen along Porters Creek Road in Great Smoky Mountains National Park following torrential rain on July 12. National Park Service

    Flooding causes Smokies damage, prompts water advisory for Sevierville 

    SEVIERVILLE Extremely heavy rain on July 12 in the Smoky Mountains caused a cascade of problems now just coming to light.

    Sevierville and Sevier County issued a boil-water advisory early Thursday after debris flushed by Tuesday’s floodwaters clogged the city water utility’s main intake on the French Broad River, leading to pressure decreases that opened up lines to possible outside contamination.

    In Great Smoky Mountains National Park, Greenbrier campground was closed indefinitely after the swollen Middle Prong of the Little Pigeon River wiped out roads, trails and bridges in the area.

  • Clean sweep: Volunteers remove tons of trash from Smokies in largest one-day cleanup
    in News

    Clean Up PileVolunteers who helped with the Save our Smokies cleanup on April 23 are shown here among their booty. Anna Lawrence/Hellbender Press

    Amid the booze bottles and toilet paper, it’s ‘incredible what we found here’

    Cleanup crews cleared garbage Earth Day weekend across Great Smoky Mountains National Park from mountain crests to the shores of Fontana Lake.

    Save Our Smokies, which organized the April 23 event, called it the largest single cleanup ever attempted in the park. Volunteers wrangled some 5,000 pounds of garbage.

    Save our Smokies Vice President Benny Braden said the organization removed 10,133 pounds of trash in all of 2021.

    “Litter is a big problem. We can clean up a location and two months later we have to be back there because it’s worse than when we started,” Braden said in an interview Saturday morning at the Tremont section of the national park. “What gives us hope is our volunteers showing up,” he said, citing their tireless dedication.

  • Blount County Commission committee rallies against Smokies parking fees ahead of superintendent Q&A
    in News

    GATLINBURG Great Smoky Mountains National Park Superintendent Cassius Cash hosted a dgital meeting April 14 urging the implementation of a $5 daily parking fee for Smokies visitors to raise money for park maintenance, law enforcement and visitor services.

    The meeting included an overview presentation introducing the rate changes and a question and answer session. 

  • New digital maps outline precious pockets of remaining U.S. biodiversity and the threats they face
    in News

    Indiana batThe endangered Indiana bat is among threatened and endangered species in Great Smoky Mountains National Park.  U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

    Southern Appalachians show red as a warning on new detailed biodiversity maps 

    This story was originally published by the Sylva Herald.

    SYLVA Great Smoky Mountains National Park has long been known for its abundance of different species of flora and fauna.

    Credit old mountains in a warm, sunny and wet region with varying types of climate, soil and stone for that large number.

    “The park is almost certainly the most biodiverse national park in North America,” said Paul Super, national park science coordinator. “And certainly the most studied of any national park.”

    A group of environmental organizations recently put together a series of maps illustrating the regions with the biggest threats to their biodiversity, and the area around Jackson County and the national park showed up in the red, showing risk. One such map, based on NatureServe data, is among the most detailed maps of endangered and threatened species ever produced.

  • Parson Branch Road improvements under way in Smokies

    Parson Branch RoadDead hemlocks are seen along Parson Branch Road near Cades Cove. National Park Service

    CADES COVE Great Smoky Mountains National Park contractors began removing at least 800 dead hemlock trees along Parson Branch Road, an eight-mile primitive backcountry road that connects Cades Cove with U.S. 129 on the western edge of the park.

    The road has been closed since 2016 because of the tree hazards and damage to the road surface. The hemlocks succumbed to the hemlock woolly adelgid, an exotic insect that has wreaked havoc on hemlock stands and their accompanying ecosystems.

    The road passes several trailheads, and is used by emergency vehicles as needed. The park initially identified some 1,700 trees that posed a hazard to the adjacent roadway, but that number has naturally declined by about half over the past six years.

    Friends of Great Smoky Mountains National Park provided $100,000 for the hazard-mitigation project. That was matched with $50,000 from the federal government.

    Once the dead trees are removed, work will begin to rehabilitate the roadway and ensure its safety. 

    The roadway could reopen this summer, according to a news release from the National Park Service.

  • It’s Sirius: Light pollution blots out the night sky but pockets of true darkness remain
    in News

    Southeast at nightThe Southeast is seen at night from the International Space Station. NASA

    Dark Sky parks, including some in East Tennessee, offer true views of heaven

    “Look up at the sky. There is a light, a beauty up there, that no shadow can touch.”  J. R. R. Tolkien  

    WARTBURG Those who came before us read the night sky like we read maps today.  

    In ancient times, pointing to the stars, they imagined creatures, mythological heroes and common every-day objects. Because of their fixed positions, the constellations became a foolproof way to navigate across vast, featureless deserts and expansive seas. The stars marked the changing seasons and the passage of time. The star patterns were memorized and taught to each new generation.

  • Naturalists have documented 77 new species in Smokies since 2011
    in News
    Celithemis elisa femaleThe calico pennant dragonfly (Celithemis elisa) is among 77 new species discovered in Great Smoky Mountains National Park over the last decade. Wikipedia Commons

    Apps and public research help uncover new layers of life in Southern Appalachia

    This article was originally published by Smoky Mountain News.

    Visitors armed only with a free app and love of nature have documented more than 4,000 species in Great Smoky Mountains National Park since 2011, according to the nonprofit Discover Life in America, including 77 not previously documented in the park by anyone else. 

    DLiA, which manages the All Taxa Biodiversity Inventory project that aims to catalogue all species residing in the extremely diverse park, recently analyzed more than 71,000 records from the app, iNaturalist, to discover the impact these casual observations have made on the project.