The Environmental Journal of Southern Appalachia
Tuesday, 12 November 2024 13:07

A long, sad tale of when coal ash filled a valley so low

Written by

kingston tm 2008357In the early morning hours of Dec. 22, 2008, the earthen wall of a containment pond at Tennessee’s Kingston Fossil Plant gave way. The breach released 1.3 million cubic meters (1.7 cubic yards) of sludge, infiltrating a nearby river and damaging dozens of homes.  NASA Earth Observatory

Journalist’s book offers deep sweep of 2008 coal-ash disaster at TVA’s Kingston coal plant

CHATTANOOGA — Jared Sullivan’s book, Valley So Low, is “A courtroom drama about the victims of one of the largest environmental disasters in US history — and the country lawyer who challenged the notion that, in America, justice can be bought.” Those words from the publisher’s dust jacket sum up the story, but the pathos of workers, certain that they got sick on the job, and the lawyer’s struggle against a well-funded corporate defense, is in the details.

Most residents of the Tennessee Valley remember the 2008 disaster when a wall of a coal ash slurry rushed out of the Kingston Steam Plant, flooding the Emory River and inundating 300 acres of the surrounding countryside. 

Sullivan offered insight into the story to an audience in Chattanooga in October. When workers fell ill after the cleanup, local personal injury lawyer Jim Scott challenged Jacob’s Engineering, a private company the Tennessee Valley Authority contracted to manage the cleanup. Scott was the only lawyer willing to take their case, according to Sullivan. 

During his presentation at Arts Build in Chattanooga, Sullivan gave a thumbnail historical sketch of the Tennessee Valley Authority. The agency was a cornerstone of Franklin D. Roosevelt’s New Deal designed to provide electricity and bring prosperity to the South. Sullivan spoke of some good things the agency has done, so his view of the agency is not all negative. 

Despite that, he presents a compelling story of a wall of toxic sludge breaking free from an earthen dam and damaging properties downstream. According to the book, the temperature was 14 degrees, so cold the pipes had frozen at a local McDonald’s. The coal-ash mound had grown into a topographic feature over more than 50 years of operations at the steam plant. More than a billion gallons of coal ash slurry broke loose, filled a lagoon, inundated the Emory River and filled a channel forty feet deep. Some slurry also entered the Clinch River. 

Houses on a peninsula below the steam plant suffered damage, but that was only the beginning. Then came the cleanup, during which crews worked day and night. Sullivan said many people were anxious to join the crews because the spill happened shortly after the 2008 economic downturn. People were out of work and desperate. Then many of them became desperately ill with lung and brain cancer and leukemia. 

In their lawsuit, the plaintiffs argued they had not been thoroughly informed of the inherent health risks in dealing with coal ash, nor provided with protective gear while doing the cleanup. The case became a long-term project and many of the plaintiffs died during the process. Jacobs Engineering settled the case in 2023. The company disagreed with Sullivan’s conclusions and a statement appears here

Though he won the case, Scott, the attorney, suffered personal and economic hardship.

The book has extensive footnotes; the contractor in charge of the cleanup has disputed the story. 

Sullivan has written for Men’s Journal, Field and Stream, The New Yorker, Time, Garden and Gun, and USA Today.

Rate this item
(1 Vote)
Last modified on Tuesday, 19 November 2024 23:59